
Happy Thanksgiving, Good Man readers! I hope you’ll be celebrating the holiday with people you care about and all your sweet furry friends. If you’re hosting dinner this year, major props to you! You’re probably super busy right now. If you’re the sous chef, the chopper of veggies, nice going, you! Uniform knife cuts are an artform! If you’re like our little foursome and you’ve opted to do take-out this year, that’s great too! You’re supporting the local economy and saving on clean-up! Maybe you’re serving dinner to people in need in your community. If so, full-on respect to you, good person! And maybe your only obligation is to show up on time and to bring the wine. You, my friend, are a hero who doesn’t require a cape! I guess what I’m trying to say here is, no matter who you are, where you are, and how you’re planning to celebrate, you’re important and deserve a hearty pat on the shoulder for your contributions.
The fact that you’ve decided to stop by this website with so much on your plate (so to speak) right now is another reason to give you some well-earned praise. You’ve contributed to this blog in so many ways even at a time when blogs aren’t exactly the trendiest of communication outlets. Seriously, am I the only person who’s still blogging these days? But you, my friend, have stuck it out with me all these years and I appreciate you every time you pay a visit. So thank you!
OK, so this may seem a little jarring and weird, but I’d now like to dial down the happy talk a notch or two and focus on a Thanksgiving that was a little less thankful and a little more filled with dread. It was a Thanksgiving in which one of the participants was coping with a problem so huge, it probably put a damper on the whole day for him, even though everyone else was likely oblivious to his inner turmoil. I’m referring to the Thanksgiving of 1952 in the Tammen household. That was the Thanksgiving when Ron Tammen came home midway through the first semester of his sophomore year with a tremendous secret.
The center of all the action in today’s post is the Tammen’s house at 21001 Hillgrove Avenue in Maple Heights, Ohio. Thanksgiving had fallen on November 27 that year, which is late—like this year, only a day later. The temperatures had dropped from a high of 62 degrees the previous day to only 36 degrees on Thanksgiving. Most of the attendees were clad in sweaters, no doubt.
Almost everyone in the family was together for the holiday—Marjorie and Ron Tammen, Sr., Marcia and Robert, the youngest Tammens, plus Ron Jr. and Richard, who’d driven home from Miami University. They’d be in town for a few days until their drive back to Oxford on Sunday.
As always, Marjorie Tammen would be on chef duty.
One Tammen was missing, however. John, the eldest Tammen brother, had recently failed spectacularly at an opportunity of a lifetime and was in the process of making some major life adjustments. After Mr. Tammen had given him “the talk” and told him that he was on his own in terms of funding any higher learning aspirations he might have, he managed to earn a full ride—to an Ivy League school, no less. In the fall of 1950, he and 13 other young men from Northeast Ohio were awarded a prestigious scholarship to Princeton University. He was destined for success. But by the fall of 1952, Princeton was a bitter memory for him. Prior to the start of his freshman year, he’d fallen hard for a girl named Joyce, and had trouble concentrating on anything else. His grades were so bad, he was asked to leave midway through his sophomore year.** In February 1952, John had enlisted in the Air Force and he married Joyce that July. The brother Ron had always idolized had flunked out, and Ron made no effort to hide his disappointment. He was so angry at him for his failure, all because of a girl, that he told him he didn’t want to see him again, which was an over-the-top, childish reaction. It was probably a good thing that John and Joyce didn’t join the others for Thanksgiving that year. There would have been tension at the table. ** (Note: An email exchange with a representative of Princeton in 2023 revealed that he was enrolled there from September 18, 1950, to February 8, 1952. While fact-checking this post, I found that John’s student records are now available in Princeton University’s Archives and I’m attempting to obtain electronic copies of them. If I’m successful, I’ll let you know.)
Still, Ron was probably also regretting his unsympathetic, high-and-mighty reaction to his brother’s plight right about then. He probably could have used his brother’s listening ear.

As for the presence of any extended family members, Marjorie’s sister, Mary McCann, would have surely been invited to Thanksgiving dinner. Mary was a late bloomer when it came to men. Despite her beauty and kind, compassionate nature, she didn’t date much and wouldn’t get married for another three years, at the age of 45. Until then (and probably even after) she could always be called upon to lend a hand with her younger sister’s family. She would’ve made a great sous chef for Marjorie that day. Also, Marjorie’s and Mary’s mother, Floranell McCann, was living in Cleveland with Mary, so Mary would have brought her along. If the two of them were there, Marjorie would’ve needed to get out an extra leaf or two for the dining room table.
What they did before dinner
As delicious smells wafted in from the kitchen, courtesy of Marjorie and Aunt Mary, the men, grandmother, and children could probably be found in the living room on the sofa, in a comfy chair, or on the floor entertaining themselves. Mr. Tammen was probably reading the paper. Floranell might have been doing needlepoint. Marcia, Robert, Richard, and Ron were probably watching TV, and maybe playing cards or a board game at the same time.
There were two parades on TV that morning. The Gimbels Thanksgiving Day Parade out of Philadelphia began airing at 10:30 a.m. Hopalong Cassidy (aka actor William Boyd) and his horse Topper were the headliners for that one. No offense to Mr. Cassidy/Boyd, but I’m thinking they probably turned the channel to Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, out of New York, when it came on at 11:00 a.m. It featured celebrities like Garry Moore, Jackie Gleason, Bozo the Clown, and Lassie, as well as giant balloons such as Mighty Mouse, a crocodile, a rainbow trout, and the debut of Spaceman. This was the 26th annual Macy’s Parade, which means that the Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade started in 1926, and that makes this year’s parade 100 years old, but you probably already knew that. In celebration, we’ll likely walk to our usual spot on Central Park West and watch a few balloons go by. (The balloons are the only things we can see from our vantage point.) If so, I’ll add a pic or a video to this post after the fact. Feel free to check back then. I don’t envision that we’ll get to see the blue hippo, but it would be wonderful if we did. I, like all of you, am heartbroken over the loss of Fiona.
The menu
In conducting my research for this post, I’ve come to learn that Thanksgiving dinner hasn’t changed that much since the 1950s. Although I’m taking a wild stab at what Ron and his family ate in 1952, I’ll bet the below menu comes pretty close. If you’d like to reproduce Ron’s dinner, here’s how, with extra points available if you incorporate certain details for authenticity.

Turkey
Stuffing
Mashed potatoes
Sweet potatoes
(Extra points if they have mini marshmallows on top)
Gravy
(Extra points if it contains giblets, or chopped-up organ meat, as well as chopped-up hard-boiled eggs)
Green beans
(Extra points if it’s just the plain kind, not a green bean casserole, which wasn’t invented until 1955 and didn’t become a Thanksgiving staple until at least the 1960s)
Cranberry sauce
(Extra points if it’s in the shape of the can it came in)
Rolls
(Extra points if they’re those little Parker House rolls and if you serve them with oleo margarine instead of butter)
For dessert: Pumpkin pie
(No extra points. This one’s mandatory)
Granted, some things have changed a little over the years. Somewhere on the table was probably a decorative compartmentalized plate with “relishes,” which was the term for 1950s-era crudités. These included celery hearts, radishes, olives (both black and green), cloyingly sweet gherkin pickles, and even sweeter pickled watermelon rinds. (People liked their relishes sugary back then.)

If you really want to hit the ball out of the park in replicating the Tammen dinner, there’s this: About a week before Thanksgiving, the Associated Press had published a recipe for creamed onions, probably because their editors felt it would be an affordable side dish to feed a crowd. It involved boiling two pounds of sliced onions and then heating a concoction of powdered milk, flour, salt, pepper, paprika, and water over a double boiler and mixing in the onions with butter or margarine. Creamed onions were served in households all over suburban America that year, so it seems plausible that the Tammens had a bowlful on their table as well. Whatever they lacked in color and texture, I’m sure they made up for in milky-oniony goodness.
If you decide to try this, please send me a photo at rontammenproject[at]gmail[dot]com and I’ll post it on this website. If anything, I think they’d make a great conversation starter.
The topics of discussion
Speaking of conversation starters, I know at least three topics that were discussed around the Tammens’ Thanksgiving dinner table. I can’t even remember what the people I’m usually with have talked about over the years at Thanksgiving other than what a great cook my brother is and our favorite dogs in the dog show, but I’m 100% certain about these topics. Guys, it’s like we’ve finally conquered time travel.
President Hahne
On the night of Tuesday, November 25, 1952, two days before Thanksgiving, Ernest H. Hahne, president of Miami University since 1946, died. He hadn’t been well for roughly a year and he’d been spending a lot of time in Florida recuperating from whatever it was that ailed him. The newspapers were extremely tight-lipped and only said that he died of an illness. Ron and Richard may not have heard the news concerning Dr. Hahne’s death until that Thursday. Students were excused from classes at noon on Wednesday, so they may have missed any articles that were published in the local newspapers that day. But on page 62 of Thursday’s Cleveland Plain Dealer was a fairly lengthy article titled “Miami U. Head’s Rites Tomorrow” with a photo of the 62-year-old administrator. His funeral was scheduled for the next day, Friday, November 28. By early December, the university would be forming a committee to select their new president. Representing the public on the selection committee would be Reuben B. Robertson, Jr., president of Champion Paper and Fibre Company, who employed Dorothy Craig, the writer of a check to Ron Tammen before he disappeared. But that’s all in the future. On this Thanksgiving day, the Tammens were saying nice things about President Hahne and lamenting his passing.

The election
On Tuesday, November 4, 1952, General Dwight D. Eisenhower was elected the 34th President of the United States, with Richard Nixon becoming his VP. I’m sure the Tammens liked Ike and they probably didn’t mind Nixon either, so they probably shared positive feelings about the two men over dinner. Soon enough, certain members of the new administration and other officials in the federal government will be making decisions and engaging in activities that will affect Ron’s life directly—so much so that, by next year at this time, he’ll be long gone and his family won’t be seeing him ever again. But, at this point at least, Mr. and Mrs. Tammen as well as Ron and maybe Richard were probably talking optimistically about the direction in which the country appeared to be headed.

The Campus Owls
You know how it is when a family gets together and one or two of the family members are home from college? Conversations tend to revolve around the college kids. How are classes? What activities are you involved in? Are you seeing anyone? Maybe the adults feel a need to keep the student interested and engaged. Maybe the college student hasn’t honed his or her own conversational skills just yet. Whatever the reason, whenever a college student is in the room, adults will grill them with questions. They just will.
So I can hear Mr. and Mrs. Tammen, Aunt Mary, and Grandma Floranell asking Ron and Richard all sorts of questions about life at Miami. I can also imagine Ron handling the questions directed at him with dexterity, entertaining questions about the topics he considered safe and batting away the ones having to do with the topic he wasn’t ready to talk about, like, ever. Ron’s favorite topic was the Campus Owls, so I’m sure he’d mentally prepared talking points on that subject that he could launch into as soon as he found an opening—talking point #1: their latest gigs; talking point #2: their play list; talking point #3: the individual band members; talking point #4: the money. When he ran out of things to say about the Owls, he likely provided commentary about his other three activities, namely, his life as a residence hall counselor, his fraternity, Delta Tau Delta, and how things were going with the wrestling team—anything to avoid the most obvious question that would be asked of him, likely by his father.
The subject that wasn’t discussed
The question that Ron was dreading so much was how his classes were going, because they weren’t going well. Two classes in particular were stressing him out: General Psychology and Principles of Economics. Both were required for a bachelor’s degree in business and both involved spending 3 hours each week in lectures plus additional hours studying on his own. Unlike John’s full ride to Princeton, Ron had been cobbling together his education at Miami through the money he earned with the Campus Owls and as a counselor in Fisher Hall, as well as through a scholarship from the Cleveland District Golf Association. The golf scholarship required that Ron maintain a B average in his courses, something that he was having trouble doing.
If I’d been there, I might have felt an urge to say something mean to young Ron as a reminder of how he treated his brother. Something like: “Not so easy, is it, Mr. Goody Two-Shoes?” Ron wasn’t having girl problems like John, and he wasn’t failing his courses, but he was struggling. He could lose his scholarship if he didn’t do something to get out of this dilemma. He probably saw his predicament as vastly different from John’s, but it really wasn’t. John lost his scholarship because of his grades, which is exactly what Ron was in danger of. On second thought, maybe Ron was well aware of how similar their situations were.
How this could happen to either one of them, let alone both, is baffling. They were both shining stars at Maple Heights High School. During their respective senior years, John was vice president of the National Honor Society and Ron was president. They were all about studying hard and getting good grades to get ahead in life.
For probably the first time in his life, Ron’s studiousness wasn’t working for him. He decided that he needed to withdraw from both courses. There was no other way out.
Ron went to his adviser, J. Belden Dennison, who would need to sign off on the withdrawals. Mr. Dennison would have told him that students had between 7 and 11 weeks from the start of classes to officially withdraw from a course. If Ron had a passing grade at the time of his withdrawal, he’d get a WP. If he was failing, he’d get a WF. If he withdrew after 11 weeks, regardless of his grade, he’d get a WF.
Ron’s transcripts don’t show us whether he got a WP or a WF. We only see the Ws. I think he was likely passing with Cs or even Ds though. If he’d been failing, I’d think he would have experienced repercussions during his second semester, such as from his counseling position. There were no signs of that.
What’s most important here are the cut-off dates. First semester classes started on Friday, September 19, 1952. That means that Ron had between November 7, 1952 (7 weeks after classes started), and December 5, 1952 (11 weeks after they started), to withdraw with a passing grade. December 5 was one week and a day after Thanksgiving. I don’t think Ron would have waited until the end to withdraw, risking a failing grade. For that reason, it’s highly likely that Ron had already withdrawn from both classes by the time he and his brother had driven home for Thanksgiving.
When Ron Tammen came home, he was only taking 11 hours of course work and was no longer a full-time student. In addition, because he’d dropped two required courses, he was already falling far behind in his degree program. I can’t imagine Ron sharing this tidbit at the dinner table when Mr. Tammen asked him how his classes were going. No way.
Come to think of it, I don’t think Ron’s parents were told that he’d dropped two courses during the first semester of his sophomore year just as I don’t think they were aware that he dropped General Psychology again the next semester. At least, not before he disappeared. For all they knew, Ron was doing swimmingly in school.
Mr. Tammen had said so himself in 1976 in the half-hour documentary, The Phantom of Oxford. When recalling his son, he said: “He just seemed to have fun the whole time he was there. There was never anything at all that would indicate there was a (laugh) he had a problem or a thing was bothering him. Nothing at all.”
The Cleveland District Golf Association knew that he had a problem, though. They’d requested a copy of Ron’s transcripts on January 14, 1953, one week before the start of finals for that first semester. I wonder what they said to Ron when they discovered he was no longer a full-time student.
Did they yank away his scholarship at that point? I don’t know. But I think that the Thanksgiving of 1952 was a turning point for Ron. In five months, he’d be gone for good, and no one would be asking him those dreaded, difficult questions anymore.
*****
And what about you? How will you be spending the holiday? Do you have any dreaded, difficult questions for me? In the meantime, here’s a photo of my sweet boy Herbie, who I miss every day. Our annual trip to NYC is going to feel different this year.

It’s been decided that we will patronize the local Chinese buffet on Thanksgiving, as one kid will be out of town with a friend and the other loves the Chinese buffet. Nobody in our little household is really into turkey and the rest, and the relatives with whom we used to celebrate have moved to warmer climes.
May your holidays be filled with loving memories of Herbie and with the blessings of the Cat Distribution System, which is always aware of our particular needs. Did I know that I needed a pair of three day old kittens at the beginning of September? I certainly did not. But the CDS did and now our home is filled with delightful furry chaos!
Eating Chinese and playing with two kitties sounds like a PERFECT way to spend the holiday! Have a wonderful time!
My dad got his last cat Pouss at 76 and they both passed 18 years later. If you want to see 94 like him I highly recommend having a kitty to look after. 🙂
That’s incredible! My family is generally pre-programmed to die at 81, but we’ll see how it goes! 😁😸
Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours and all your readers. I’ve never had a Thanksgiving Dinner but I guess that’s the price I pay for being English. 😉
Oh, thank you! I appreciate you international readers so much!
Oh I’m so sorry to hear of the loss of Herbie. Very very best from me and my cats. I hope you will get another kitty soon.
That’s so sweet—thank you. I’m on the fence about getting another one, since I’m no spring chicken and cats live a long time. I’d have to will him/her/them to someone. But if a cat should adopt me, I will accept. I even have cat food all ready to go, just in case someone shows up at the back door.
I know you’re missing Herbie, Jen, and I will certainly miss photos of him peering out the window in NYC. Tom and will be contributing a couple homemade desserts and salad to a carry-out dinner at our youngest son’s house. Just us four adults and a three-year old this year so we’re keeping it easy. When I look at your posted 1952 Thanksgiving Menu (where I would have been 9 months old) all I can say is “no thanks”. Hope you have a wonderful holiday in the city and enjoy the parade!🦃🍗🥧
Great to hear from you, Deb! Your Thanksgiving sounds perfect—I like small and meaningful gatherings. So…I wasn’t able to convince you to make creamed onions this year, eh? 😆 I hope you have a wonderful Thanksgiving too!