Blog

Ron Tammen’s Last Thanksgiving

Vintage Thanksgiving dinner still life with roast turkey, flowers, tableware, pie, cranberry sauce, and the words “Thanksgiving Day.”
An old-fashioned Thanksgiving table; Public domain

Happy Thanksgiving, Good Man readers! I hope you’ll be celebrating the holiday with people you care about and all your sweet furry friends. If you’re hosting dinner this year, major props to you! You’re probably super busy right now. If you’re the sous chef, the chopper of veggies, nice going, you! Uniform knife cuts are an artform! If you’re like our little foursome and you’ve opted to do take-out this year, that’s great too! You’re supporting the local economy and saving on clean-up! Maybe you’re serving dinner to people in need in your community. If so, full-on respect to you, good person! And maybe your only obligation is to show up on time and to bring the wine. You, my friend, are a hero who doesn’t require a cape! I guess what I’m trying to say here is, no matter who you are, where you are, and how you’re planning to celebrate, you’re important and deserve a hearty pat on the shoulder for your contributions.

The fact that you’ve decided to stop by this website with so much on your plate (so to speak) right now is another reason to give you some well-earned praise. You’ve contributed to this blog in so many ways even at a time when blogs aren’t exactly the trendiest of communication outlets. Seriously, am I the only person who’s still blogging these days? But you, my friend, have stuck it out with me all these years and I appreciate you every time you pay a visit. So thank you!

OK, so this may seem a little jarring and weird, but I’d now like to dial down the happy talk a notch or two and focus on a Thanksgiving that was a little less thankful and a little more filled with dread. It was a Thanksgiving in which one of the participants was coping with a problem so huge, it probably put a damper on the whole day for him, even though everyone else was likely oblivious to his inner turmoil. I’m referring to the Thanksgiving of 1952 in the Tammen household. That was the Thanksgiving when Ron Tammen came home midway through the first semester of his sophomore year with a tremendous secret.

The center of all the action in today’s post is the Tammen’s house at 21001 Hillgrove Avenue in Maple Heights, Ohio. Thanksgiving had fallen on November 27 that year, which is late—like this year, only a day later. The temperatures had dropped from a high of 62 degrees the previous day to only 36 degrees on Thanksgiving. Most of the attendees were clad in sweaters, no doubt.

Almost everyone in the family was together for the holiday—Marjorie and Ron Tammen, Sr., Marcia and Robert, the youngest Tammens, plus Ron Jr. and Richard, who’d driven home from Miami University. They’d be in town for a few days until their drive back to Oxford on Sunday.

As always, Marjorie Tammen would be on chef duty.

One Tammen was missing, however. John, the eldest Tammen brother, had recently failed spectacularly at an opportunity of a lifetime and was in the process of making some major life adjustments. After Mr. Tammen had given him “the talk” and told him that he was on his own in terms of funding any higher learning aspirations he might have, he managed to earn a full ride—to an Ivy League school, no less. In the fall of 1950, he and 13 other young men from Northeast Ohio were awarded a prestigious scholarship to Princeton University. He was destined for success. But by the fall of 1952, Princeton was a bitter memory for him. Prior to the start of his freshman year, he’d fallen hard for a girl named Joyce, and had trouble concentrating on anything else. His grades were so bad, he was asked to leave midway through his sophomore year.** In February 1952, John had enlisted in the Air Force and he married Joyce that July. The brother Ron had always idolized had flunked out, and Ron made no effort to hide his disappointment. He was so angry at him for his failure, all because of a girl, that he told him he didn’t want to see him again, which was an over-the-top, childish reaction. It was probably a good thing that John and Joyce didn’t join the others for Thanksgiving that year. There would have been tension at the table. ** (Note: An email exchange with a representative of Princeton in 2023 revealed that he was enrolled there from September 18, 1950, to February 8, 1952. While fact-checking this post, I found that John’s student records are now available in Princeton University’s Archives and I’m attempting to obtain electronic copies of them. If I’m successful, I’ll let you know.)

Still, Ron was probably also regretting his unsympathetic, high-and-mighty reaction to his brother’s plight right about then. He probably could have used his brother’s listening ear.

Black-and-white portrait of a young man wearing a suit, collared shirt, and patterned tie.
John Tammen’s senior high school photo, before he flunked out of Princeton

As for the presence of any extended family members, Marjorie’s sister, Mary McCann, would have surely been invited to Thanksgiving dinner. Mary was a late bloomer when it came to men. Despite her beauty and kind, compassionate nature, she didn’t date much and wouldn’t get married for another three years, at the age of 45. Until then (and probably even after) she could always be called upon to lend a hand with her younger sister’s family. She would’ve made a great sous chef for Marjorie that day. Also, Marjorie’s and Mary’s mother, Floranell McCann, was living in Cleveland with Mary, so Mary would have brought her along. If the two of them were there, Marjorie would’ve needed to get out an extra leaf or two for the dining room table.

What they did before dinner

As delicious smells wafted in from the kitchen, courtesy of Marjorie and Aunt Mary, the men, grandmother, and children could probably be found in the living room on the sofa, in a comfy chair, or on the floor entertaining themselves. Mr. Tammen was probably reading the paper. Floranell might have been doing needlepoint. Marcia, Robert, Richard, and Ron were probably watching TV, and maybe playing cards or a board game at the same time.

There were two parades on TV that morning. The Gimbels Thanksgiving Day Parade out of Philadelphia began airing at 10:30 a.m. Hopalong Cassidy (aka actor William Boyd) and his horse Topper were the headliners for that one. No offense to Mr. Cassidy/Boyd, but I’m thinking they probably turned the channel to Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, out of New York, when it came on at 11:00 a.m. It featured celebrities like Garry Moore, Jackie Gleason, Bozo the Clown, and Lassie, as well as giant balloons such as Mighty Mouse, a crocodile, a rainbow trout, and the debut of Spaceman. This was the 26th annual Macy’s Parade, which means that the Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade started in 1926, and that makes this year’s parade 100 years old, but you probably already knew that. In celebration, we’ll likely walk to our usual spot on Central Park West and watch a few balloons go by. (The balloons are the only things we can see from our vantage point.) If so, I’ll add a pic or a video to this post after the fact. Feel free to check back then. I don’t envision that we’ll get to see the blue hippo, but it would be wonderful if we did. I, like all of you, am heartbroken over the loss of Fiona.

The menu

In conducting my research for this post, I’ve come to learn that Thanksgiving dinner hasn’t changed that much since the 1950s. Although I’m taking a wild stab at what Ron and his family ate in 1952, I’ll bet the below menu comes pretty close. If you’d like to reproduce Ron’s dinner, here’s how, with extra points available if you incorporate certain details for authenticity.

Bowl of creamy mashed potatoes on a red plate
A bowl of mashed potatoes and nothing else, not even a sprig of parsley to make the photo more appealing; Public domain

Turkey

Stuffing

Mashed potatoes

Sweet potatoes
(Extra points if they have mini marshmallows on top)

Gravy
(Extra points if it contains giblets, or chopped-up organ meat, as well as chopped-up hard-boiled eggs)

Green beans
(Extra points if it’s just the plain kind, not a green bean casserole, which wasn’t invented until 1955 and didn’t become a Thanksgiving staple until at least the 1960s)

Cranberry sauce
(Extra points if it’s in the shape of the can it came in)

Rolls
(Extra points if they’re those little Parker House rolls and if you serve them with oleo margarine instead of butter)

For dessert: Pumpkin pie
(No extra points. This one’s mandatory)

Granted, some things have changed a little over the years. Somewhere on the table was probably a decorative compartmentalized plate with “relishes,” which was the term for 1950s-era crudités. These included celery hearts, radishes, olives (both black and green), cloyingly sweet gherkin pickles, and even sweeter pickled watermelon rinds. (People liked their relishes sugary back then.)

Vegetable platter with creamy dip, carrots, celery, zucchini, radishes, olives, tomatoes, peppers, and cauliflower
A relish tray; This one’s a little healthier than what they used to have in the 1950s but you get the gist; Public domain

If you really want to hit the ball out of the park in replicating the Tammen dinner, there’s this: About a week before Thanksgiving, the Associated Press had published a recipe for creamed onions, probably because their editors felt it would be an affordable side dish to feed a crowd. It involved boiling two pounds of sliced onions and then heating a concoction of powdered milk, flour, salt, pepper, paprika, and water over a double boiler and mixing in the onions with butter or margarine. Creamed onions were served in households all over suburban America that year, so it seems plausible that the Tammens had a bowlful on their table as well. Whatever they lacked in color and texture, I’m sure they made up for in milky-oniony goodness.

If you decide to try this, please send me a photo at rontammenproject[at]gmail[dot]com and I’ll post it on this website. If anything, I think they’d make a great conversation starter.

The topics of discussion

Speaking of conversation starters, I know at least three topics that were discussed around the Tammens’ Thanksgiving dinner table. I can’t even remember what the people I’m usually with have talked about over the years at Thanksgiving other than what a great cook my brother is and our favorite dogs in the dog show, but I’m 100% certain about these topics. Guys, it’s like we’ve finally conquered time travel.

President Hahne

On the night of Tuesday, November 25, 1952, two days before Thanksgiving, Ernest H. Hahne, president of Miami University since 1946, died. He hadn’t been well for roughly a year and he’d been spending a lot of time in Florida recuperating from whatever it was that ailed him. The newspapers were extremely tight-lipped and only said that he died of an illness. Ron and Richard may not have heard the news concerning Dr. Hahne’s death until that Thursday. Students were excused from classes at noon on Wednesday, so they may have missed any articles that were published in the local newspapers that day. But on page 62 of Thursday’s Cleveland Plain Dealer was a fairly lengthy article titled “Miami U. Head’s Rites Tomorrow” with a photo of the 62-year-old administrator. His funeral was scheduled for the next day, Friday, November 28. By early December, the university would be forming a committee to select their new president. Representing the public on the selection committee would be Reuben B. Robertson, Jr., president of Champion Paper and Fibre Company, who employed Dorothy Craig, the writer of a check to Ron Tammen before he disappeared. But that’s all in the future. On this Thanksgiving day, the Tammens were saying nice things about President Hahne and lamenting his passing.

Black-and-white portrait of a bespectacled man in a suit and tie.
Ernest H. Hahne; Wikimedia Commons; no known copyright restrictions

The election

On Tuesday, November 4, 1952, General Dwight D. Eisenhower was elected the 34th President of the United States, with Richard Nixon becoming his VP. I’m sure the Tammens liked Ike and they probably didn’t mind Nixon either, so they probably shared positive feelings about the two men over dinner. Soon enough, certain members of the new administration and other officials in the federal government will be making decisions and engaging in activities that will affect Ron’s life directly—so much so that, by next year at this time, he’ll be long gone and his family won’t be seeing him ever again. But, at this point at least, Mr. and Mrs. Tammen as well as Ron and maybe Richard were probably talking optimistically about the direction in which the country appeared to be headed.

Portrait of former U.S. President Dwight D. Eisenhower wearing a gray suit and blue patterned tie.
President Dwight D. Eisenhower

The Campus Owls

You know how it is when a family gets together and one or two of the family members are home from college? Conversations tend to revolve around the college kids. How are classes? What activities are you involved in? Are you seeing anyone? Maybe the adults feel a need to keep the student interested and engaged. Maybe the college student hasn’t honed his or her own conversational skills just yet. Whatever the reason, whenever a college student is in the room, adults will grill them with questions. They just will.

So I can hear Mr. and Mrs. Tammen, Aunt Mary, and Grandma Floranell asking Ron and Richard all sorts of questions about life at Miami. I can also imagine Ron handling the questions directed at him with dexterity, entertaining questions about the topics he considered safe and batting away the ones having to do with the topic he wasn’t ready to talk about, like, ever. Ron’s favorite topic was the Campus Owls, so I’m sure he’d mentally prepared talking points on that subject that he could launch into as soon as he found an opening—talking point #1: their latest gigs; talking point #2: their play list; talking point #3: the individual band members; talking point #4: the money. When he ran out of things to say about the Owls, he likely provided commentary about his other three activities, namely, his life as a residence hall counselor, his fraternity, Delta Tau Delta, and how things were going with the wrestling team—anything to avoid the most obvious question that would be asked of him, likely by his father.

The subject that wasn’t discussed

The question that Ron was dreading so much was how his classes were going, because they weren’t going well. Two classes in particular were stressing him out: General Psychology and Principles of Economics. Both were required for a bachelor’s degree in business and both involved spending 3 hours each week in lectures plus additional hours studying on his own. Unlike John’s full ride to Princeton, Ron had been cobbling together his education at Miami through the money he earned with the Campus Owls and as a counselor in Fisher Hall, as well as through a scholarship from the Cleveland District Golf Association. The golf scholarship required that Ron maintain a B average in his courses, something that he was having trouble doing.

If I’d been there, I might have felt an urge to say something mean to young Ron as a reminder of how he treated his brother. Something like: “Not so easy, is it, Mr. Goody Two-Shoes?” Ron wasn’t having girl problems like John, and he wasn’t failing his courses, but he was struggling. He could lose his scholarship if he didn’t do something to get out of this dilemma. He probably saw his predicament as vastly different from John’s, but it really wasn’t. John lost his scholarship because of his grades, which is exactly what Ron was in danger of. On second thought, maybe Ron was well aware of how similar their situations were.

How this could happen to either one of them, let alone both, is baffling. They were both shining stars at Maple Heights High School. During their respective senior years, John was vice president of the National Honor Society and Ron was president. They were all about studying hard and getting good grades to get ahead in life.

For probably the first time in his life, Ron’s studiousness wasn’t working for him. He decided that he needed to withdraw from both courses. There was no other way out.

Ron went to his adviser, J. Belden Dennison, who would need to sign off on the withdrawals. Mr. Dennison would have told him that students had between 7 and 11 weeks from the start of classes to officially withdraw from a course. If Ron had a passing grade at the time of his withdrawal, he’d get a WP. If he was failing, he’d get a WF. If he withdrew after 11 weeks, regardless of his grade, he’d get a WF.

Ron’s transcripts don’t show us whether he got a WP or a WF. We only see the Ws. I think he was likely passing with Cs or even Ds though. If he’d been failing, I’d think he would have experienced repercussions during his second semester, such as from his counseling position. There were no signs of that.

What’s most important here are the cut-off dates. First semester classes started on Friday, September 19, 1952.  That means that Ron had between November 7, 1952 (7 weeks after classes started), and December 5, 1952 (11 weeks after they started), to withdraw with a passing grade. December 5 was one week and a day after Thanksgiving. I don’t think Ron would have waited until the end to withdraw, risking a failing grade. For that reason, it’s highly likely that Ron had already withdrawn from both classes by the time he and his brother had driven home for Thanksgiving.

When Ron Tammen came home, he was only taking 11 hours of course work and was no longer a full-time student. In addition, because he’d dropped two required courses, he was already falling far behind in his degree program. I can’t imagine Ron sharing this tidbit at the dinner table when Mr. Tammen asked him how his classes were going. No way.

Come to think of it, I don’t think Ron’s parents were told that he’d dropped two courses during the first semester of his sophomore year just as I don’t think they were aware that he dropped General Psychology again the next semester. At least, not before he disappeared. For all they knew, Ron was doing swimmingly in school.

Mr. Tammen had said so himself in 1976 in the half-hour documentary, The Phantom of Oxford. When recalling his son, he said: “He just seemed to have fun the whole time he was there. There was never anything at all that would indicate there was a (laugh) he had a problem or a thing was bothering him. Nothing at all.”

The Cleveland District Golf Association knew that he had a problem, though. They’d requested a copy of Ron’s transcripts on January 14, 1953, one week before the start of finals for that first semester. I wonder what they said to Ron when they discovered he was no longer a full-time student.

Did they yank away his scholarship at that point? I don’t know. But I think that the Thanksgiving of 1952 was a turning point for Ron. In five months, he’d be gone for good, and no one would be asking him those dreaded, difficult questions anymore.

*****

And what about you? How will you be spending the holiday? Do you have any dreaded, difficult questions for me? In the meantime, here’s a photo of my sweet boy Herbie, who I miss every day. Our annual trip to NYC is going to feel different this year.

Cat lounging on a window seat in a bedroom with purple quilted bedding

P.S. I just heard from someone who told me that they tried to comment but were blocked by my bot blocker. If this has happened to you too, I’m very sorry. After my last post (about the FBI’s tactics in doctoring records), I was inundated with bot traffic for four days. I had to install the bot protector plugin to cut them off. Again, my apologies if you’ve experienced issues.

Here’s another way the FBI conceals the meaning of the numbers in the upper righthand corner of its records, including Ron’s 10s

(This one is so obvious, I can’t believe I didn’t think of it earlier)

Before we discuss today’s actual topic, I’d like to talk about another subject of significance, especially for people from Ohio in my general age range or older. That subject is May 4, 1970. Although I was 12 when it happened, the horrific events of that day hit particularly hard in my family. My family loved Kent—the school and the town. My parents were Kent State grads back in the 1950s. So were two aunts and an uncle. Later, my dad became a professor, then an assistant dean, at one of its regional campuses. My sister, brother, and I attended that same regional campus before transferring to Miami. I received my master’s degree from Kent. May the 4th has one meaning and one meaning only for me, and it has nothing to do with Star Wars.

For a while after it happened, there was a kind of stigma associated with Kent State. Those two words—Kent State—were all someone needed to say to evoke the iconic images of a war zone. The rocks, the tear gas, the smoldering ROTC building, the Ohio National Guard in full force, the anguished face of a 14-year-old runaway girl kneeling near a dead boy’s bleeding body. Today, I feel enormous pride for how the university has embraced its place in history, memorializing what happened and honoring the four lives that had been tragically cut short and the others permanently changed. The hope is that this unimaginable turn of events in which the U.S. military turned against its own youth—some of them attending the protest, some of them walking across a parking lot to class, none of them armed—won’t be repeated.

If anyone visits me from out of town, one of our must-see stops is the university’s May 4 Visitors Center. I show them where Jeffrey Miller, Allison Krause, Sandra Scheuer, and William Schroeder were killed in the Prentice Hall parking lot, their exact locations when the guardsmen opened fire on them marked by lighted pillars and granite nameplates. I point out the locations where nine students were shot and wounded, one of them paralyzed for life, their names now memorialized on bronze markers along with their distances from the firing line. I show them where a bullet had ripped through a metal sculpture, Solar Totem #1, which serves as surreal proof of the deadly force that was used against the sons and daughters of the tax-paying public, the very people who were paying the shooters’ salaries. (In an interview conducted by the university for the 50th anniversary of the shootings, the sculptor, Don Drumm, said: “I have let it be known to different people that I do not want that hole ever welded closed. And nobody has ever asked me to.”) To this day, no one whom I’ve taken to the site can get over how close the National Guardsmen were to the students when they aimed their M-1 rifles in their direction and began firing away. They were literally at point-blank range.

Black bollard-style pathway lights lining a paved walkway in a leafy park on a sunny autumn day
Memorial for Jeffrey Miller in the parking lot of Prentice Hall
Round National Historic Landmark plaque commemorating Thomas and Grace 1630, set in a grassy area beside a sidewalk and covered with fallen leaves.
A bronze marker shows the location where Thomas M. Grace was shot in the foot by the Ohio National Guard.
Abstract rust-colored metal sculpture in a grassy park beside a sidewalk and trees under a clear blue sky
Solar Totem #1, by sculptor Don Drumm
Close-up of a weathered outdoor metal sculpture with graffiti and a single red flower, set against autumn trees and parked cars.
The bullet hole that penetrated Drumm’s sculpture as National Guardsmen were shooting from a nearby hill, called Blanket Hill, toward the Prentice Hall parking lot

Why am I bringing all of this up? It just so happens that the events from that time have given me an assist in my Ron Tammen research. Thanks to the FBI’s investigation into Kent State in May 1970, I’ve found another way that the FBI has spread misinformation about the meaning behind the numbers in the upper righthand corner of Ron’s and others’ FBI documents.

Before I proceed to tell you what the FBI has been up to, I feel the need to point something out. Even though the FBI’s investigation was officially titled “Kent State Shooting” or “KENFOUR,” a weird mashed-up term ostensibly in reference to the four students who were killed, it had nothing to do with the shootings. For case #98-46479, the FBI was (ostensibly) only interested in finding the people who’d set fire to the ROTC building on May 2, 1970, in protest of the US invasion of Cambodia days earlier. It was the burning of the ROTC building that had led Ohio Governor James Rhodes to summon the National Guard to Kent, thus contributing to an openly hostile atmosphere of soldiers versus students that ended so tragically on May 4. As their records show, the FBI’s focus was on the students who allegedly started the fire as well as those who allegedly had helped them by thwarting the efforts of the fire fighters. The Department of Justice (DOJ) was closely monitoring the FBI’s investigation as well.

Ultimately, in October 1970, a special grand jury established by Governor Rhodes indicted 25 people. Some were Kent State students, some weren’t. One was a sociology professor. They became known as the Kent 25. These are the people who’ve led me to my latest discovery, which is playing out in other FBI records as well.

And now, Q&A time.

The May 4 Visitors Center sounds amazing.

It really is. I just described what’s outside. Inside, there are exhibits plus an extremely well-done 10-minute documentary that encapsulates what happened. Also, the staff there are friendly and helpful. If you’re ever near Kent, Ohio, I highly recommend that you pay a visit.

Remind me: What’s the FBI doing regarding the numbers in the upper righthand corner of its records?

The FBI wants us all to think that the numbers that can be found in the upper righthand corners of many, but not all, of their records are meaningless, based on a made-up alphabetical system. But I’m saying that’s total hogwash and those numbers are meaningful as all get out. I’m saying that Ron’s 10s provide valuable information about what Ron was doing after he disappeared. They also tell us that he was doing those things with the knowledge of people in the federal government.

What’s the FBI’s made-up system?

The FBI decided at some point in its history that it would be well worth its use of taxpayer dollars to devise a make-believe system in which the numbers in the upper righthand corner directly corresponded to the first letter of the subject of a memo or report. The letter was denoted by a small circle drawn slightly in front of and above it in blue pencil. Mind you, the circles and numbers weren’t made-up, and they both had a purpose. What I’m saying is that the numbers and circles had nothing to do with one another. That’s the part that the FBI had made up.

Why were they circling letters in blue pencil?

The circles in front of a key word tell us that an index card was made for that word, which would be filed alphabetically in the General Index. If it was a person’s name, the circle would be in front of their last name. If it was a broader topic, like KENFOUR, the circle would be in front of the K. Some subjects with lengthy names might have two or more circles and, therefore, that many cards, which were filed in their appropriate place in the General Index.

The General Index was the FBI’s first stop in locating a file. Staffers would look up a name in the General Index, which provided the case number or numbers related to that person or topic. That was all the info they needed to locate a file. They didn’t need additional help from a number between 1 and 11 in the upper righthand corner of a document.

How did they create their made-up system?

The FBI accomplished this con by dividing the alphabet into groups of letters and assigning a number ranging from 1 to 11 to each group.

After going through the FBI missing person records I obtained this past summer plus other FBI records, I’ve come up with the following made-up alphabetical system that they want us to believe pertains to how the numbers were assigned to the upper righthand corner:

1 – AA-BL

2 – BO-CL

3 – CO-EX

4 – FA-HA

5 – HE-KA

6 – KE-LY

7 – MA-MY

8 – N-O-P

? – Q (unsure if 8 or 9)

9 – R-SH

10 – SI-U

11 – V-Z

For example, if a subject’s name was Steve Austin, we should expect to find a 1 in the upper righthand corner. Carlos Marcello’s M would get a 7 in the upper right corner. And Ron Tammen’s T would be assigned a 10. At least, that’s what they want us to believe. The tricky part is when there are multiple names and a list of numbers. But I’m not gonna lie—they were good at making it appear as if the numbers represented the first letter of the subject’s last name or another key word. Thankfully, nobody’s perfect, not even people at the FBI, and they made mistakes.

I don’t get it. Why were they going to all that trouble if the system had no purpose?

I think they were trying to make it look as if the numbers served some sort of administrative purpose, like in filing or something, to make us think that they’re not important to the case. But based on everything I’ve read about the FBI’s filing system, my contention is that this pretend protocol makes zero sense. I believe the numbers communicated information to the agents who were working a particular case. I believe they represented an important person—either within or outside the FBI—who received one or more copies of a given memo or report. I believe the FBI doesn’t want us to figure out who those important memo recipients were. Incidentally, I don’t think they put numbers in the upper righthand corners of their records anymore. FBI records that are more recent don’t seem to have them.

It hasn’t escaped me how lucky we are about two things. First, we’re lucky that they were using the numbers at least through the 1970s when Ron received his 10s. Second, we’re lucky that Ron’s last name started with a T and the FBI allowed us to see his 10s because they fit their made-up system.

How is the FBI making it look as if the numbers are based on the alphabet?

I think they did it in several ways. In earlier posts, I discussed how I believe they would cherry-pick the records they released to the public to make it appear as if the numbers were in reference to the subjects’ last names. For example, only the people whose last names started with A through BL who also had a 1 in the upper right would be released. Same with the people whose names started with a BO through CL who also had 2’s in their upper right. (And so on, and so forth, up through the V’s through Z’s and the number 11.) That’s one way. But today, I’m revealing another way. This way is especially pertinent for cases with multiple subjects and a long list of numbers, but they used it for single subjects and numbers too.

What way is that?

What does the FBI use so frequently that we’ve practically become numb to them? What do they use with such wild abandon that we just accept them as par for the course?

I give up, what?

Redactions. They do it through redactions. For example, if a list of numbers has been written in the upper righthand corner and the subjects’ names don’t match the FBI’s made-up system, all they have to do is redact the name or names that don’t fit. That includes the option of redacting all the names if they have to. There’s no way for us to know who was written there, so there’s no way for us to figure out if the numbers fit or don’t fit. Brilliant, right?

What does this have to do with the Kent 25?

OK, I just said something that’s only partly true. I said that if they redact a name, there’s no way for us to know who was written there. But there is at least one way. If the news media covered the story, there’s a chance we can figure out who was written there. That’s what happened with the Kent 25.

Here’s a memorandum dated June 10, 1970, from FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover to Attorney General John Mitchell listing some people of interest regarding the ROTC fire.

Scanned FBI memorandum dated June 10, 1970, concerning the Kent State University ROTC building fire investigation, with handwritten annotations and redactions.
Click on image for a closer view

We can see that at least three names are redacted and possibly more if two names shared a line. Why did they redact some names but not others? Now check out the list of numbers: 1-1, 3-1, 4-1, 5-1, 7-1, 9-1, 10-1. (In my theory, the 1’s that follow the dashes show that the important person received a single copy.) You may notice that there are more redacted and unredacted names than there are numbers, but the FBI would tell us not to sweat it. In their made-up system, if two or more people’s last names were represented by the same number, that number only needed to be written once. For our purposes, the most important part of the list on the June 10 document is that the numbers 2,6,8, and 11 are missing.

In the FBI’s made-up system, the three (or more) people whose names were redacted wouldn’t have been represented by one of the four missing numbers. But guess what? I’ve found three people who were likely to have been included in that list of subjects and at least two of those people’s pretend numbers should have been included in the list. I would contend that the FBI redacted at least one of their names, and possibly two, for the sole reason that they didn’t fit the FBI’s made-up system.

You said there were 25 people. How did you narrow the names down to those three likely candidates?

It has to do with the charges that were brought against them in October 1970. Most of the Kent 25 were charged with second-degree riot. I’m not sure what that means exactly, but the feds as well as the special grand jury considered the allegations to be not as bad as crimes like attempted arson, first-degree riot, assault of a fireman, and interfering with a fireman, which included actions like pulling on fire hoses, cutting fire hoses, basically messing with the fire hoses. The people who were charged with those crimes were put at the top of the list for indictments, which tells me that they’d been at the forefront of the FBI’s investigation as well. And because the June 10 memo was written to the U.S. attorney general, I’d hypothesize that they’d want to inform him about the people who’d allegedly committed the most serious infractions.

The people whose names were unredacted in the June 10, 1970, memo were priority. They were among the first to be indicted. They were also among the earliest to be tried. There’s one exception, because, in FBI world, there’s always an exception. That exception is a guy named Dale D. Smiley. In FBI records, Dale D. Smiley admits to pulling on and cutting fire hoses, but, unlike the other people who were alleged to have done one or the other, he wasn’t indicted. His name also doesn’t appear in any news accounts pertaining to the ROTC fire—not in Kent’s student newspaper archives and not in other local and regional newspapers. Maybe he cut a deal? No clue. But if Dale D. Smiley did the things that Dale D. Smiley said he did, he got off scot-free.

Here are the names in the order in which they appeared in the FBI’s June 10, 1970, memo and the charges that were subsequently brought against them in October 1970:

REDACTED

Peter Charles Bleik (SIC, actual spelling is Bliek) – arson/1st degree riot

Douglas Charles Cormack – 1st degree riot/throwing rocks and interfering with fireman

Rick Felber – 1st degree riot/attempted arson/assaulting a fireman/interfering with fireman

Thomas Graydon Foglesong – 1st degree riot, interfering with fireman

REDACTED

REDACTED

Jerry Rupe – arson/assaulting a fireman/1st degree riot/interfering with fireman

Dale D. Smiley – NO CHARGES

Now, let’s compare those names to the list of numbers. The 1 works for Peter Bliek. The 3 works for Douglas Cormack and the 4 works for Rick Felber and Thomas Foglesong. The 5 and 7 don’t apply to anyone. I’m sure the FBI would like us to think that those are for the redacted names. The 9 works for Jerry Rupe, and the 10 works for Dale Smiley.

The people whose names I believe were redacted and their charges were:

Larry Shub – 1st degree riot/2nd degree riot/attempted arson (shed near ROTC building)

Mary Helen Nicholas – interfering with fireman

Ronald Weissenberger – 1st degree riot/2nd degree riot/inciting to riot/interfering with fireman

In the FBI’s made-up system, Larry Shub would be assigned a 9, Mary Helen Nicholas would get an 8, and Ronald Weissenberger would get an 11.

Then what happened?

In November 1971, the trials started, beginning with cases in which the special prosecutor felt he had the strongest evidence.

The first person to go on trial was Jerry Rupe. He was convicted of the misdemeanor of interfering with a fireman but nothing else. Then came Peter Bliek, whose charges were dismissed by the prosecution during his trial. Then came Larry Shub, who pleaded guilty to first-degree riot. His lawyer was seeking probation, and he was freed on bond. Next was Thomas Foglesong, who also pleaded guilty to first-degree riot. He was also freed on bond while he awaited sentencing. The fifth and final person to be tried was Mary Helen Nicholas. She was acquitted due to a lack of evidence. That same day, Tuesday, December 7, 1971, the special state prosecutor asked that the remaining 20 cases be dismissed for the same reason, a lack of evidence. Nearly everyone was elated except for two people: Jerry Rupe, who’d been sent to jail without bond for his conviction, and Rick Felber, who was already doing time on a drug conviction. In January 1972, Jerry Rupe was sentenced to six months in prison for his misdemeanor, which he served concurrently with an unrelated drug conviction. As for the two who’d pleaded guilty before the others had their charges dismissed, Thomas Foglesong’s charges were dismissed on December 30, 1971, but Larry Shub had to wait until October 1972 before he was granted probation. Don’t ask me why his charges weren’t dropped in December, like Foglesong’s. I’m not a lawyer.

When the DOJ was later asked if the federal government planned to pursue charges, their spokesperson said, “there are not sufficient legal grounds for federal prosecution.”

What happened to the National Guardsmen?

Members of the Ohio National Guard who fired their military-grade weapons into a group of unarmed students received no punishment whatsoever. Although there had been federal criminal and civil trials, the guardsmen’s claim that they were acting in self-defense was accepted by the courts. An out-of-court settlement in 1979 brought everything to a conclusion in which the wounded students and the families of the four dead students received a total of $675,000 (over $5.8 million in today’s dollars), funded by Ohio taxpayers. In addition, a statement of regret was signed by 27 guardsmen—not an apology, not a passively phrased admission that mistakes were made, just a statement saying that things happened that, in hindsight, they wished hadn’t happened. That framed statement with 28 signatures can be found on a wall at the May 4 Visitors Center. The 28th signature, which occupies the fourth line from the bottom of column #2, is that of Governor James A. Rhodes. You’d miss it if you didn’t know it was there.

Close-up of handwritten cursive text on a vintage lined document
The signature of James A. Rhodes on the statement signed by members of the Ohio National Guard as part of the 1979 settlement; I’ve blocked out the names above and below his name in this image but you can see the original document at the May 4 Visitors Center.

The statement reads as follows:

“In retrospect, the tragedy of May 4, 1970 should not have occurred. The students may have believed that they were right in continuing their mass protest in response to the Cambodian invasion, even though this protest followed the posting and reading by the University of an order to ban rallies and an order to disperse. These orders have since been determined by the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals to have been lawful.

Some of the Guardsmen on Blanket Hill, fearful and anxious from prior events, may have believed in their own minds that their lives were in danger. Hindsight suggests that another method would have resolved the confrontation. Better ways must be found to deal with such confrontations.

We devoutly wish that a means had been found to avoid the May 4 events culminating in the Guard shootings and the irreversible deaths and injuries. We deeply regret those events and are profoundly saddened by the deaths of four students and the wounding of nine others which resulted. We hope that the agreement to end this litigation will help to assuage the tragic memories regarding that sad day.”

That sucks.

I think so too. I would at least like to know who gave the order for them to commence firing.

You can find an excellent synopsis of the events here if you’d like to learn more.

Are you absolutely sure those were the three people whose names were redacted?

While I can’t say I’m 100% sure, I believe they are the three most likely people. Shub and Nicholas were among the first five who were tried, and Weissenberger’s trial loomed closely behind theirs until everyone else’s cases were dismissed. In addition, Weissenberger had one of the lengthier lists of charges against him. I was also able to rule out several other members of the Kent 25 whose names were unredacted in another memo.

Of the three, I’m most certain about Mary Helen Nicholas. Not only was she the fifth person to be tried and the first female to be indicted, but I also found an FBI record from a May 22, 1970, interview with a female whose name was also redacted. During that interview, the special agents had advised that person of her constitutional rights and also described the allegations against her, though they didn’t detail what the allegations were in the report. The woman denied the allegations and refused to discuss the topic further. The May 22 interview was two and a half weeks before the June 10 memo, so I feel confident that there should be at least one female among the redacted names.

Redacted FBI document dated May 26, 1970, describing an interview and witness details related to student demonstrations at Kent State University.
Click on image for a closer view

What’s more, only three other women were part of the Kent 25, and they were all indicted on lesser charges. Nicholas also appears to match the physical description that the agent had written in the report. Finally, the interview had been conducted by the FBI’s Buffalo Field Office because this person was living in New York at the time. Although Mary Helen Nicholas was from Akron, she had an aunt who lived in New York, and I’ve found no New York ties to the other three women. My guess is that Mary Helen moved in with her aunt for a little while after the university canceled classes for the rest of the quarter following the shootings.

What all of this means is that if the FBI’s system were real instead of made up, I believe there should at least be an 8 among that list of numbers for Nicholas and possibly an 11 for Weissenberger. Shub’s 9 was already there. It also leads me to question the 5 and 7 that were included in the list of numbers.

Why would they redact Larry Shub’s name if his number was included in the list?

That’s a great question. If the point was to confuse us, then maybe they were merely adding to the confusion. Maybe they felt they needed a little more camouflage against the 5 and 7 that had been listed. Or maybe his name was redacted for an entirely different reason. All I can say is that at least one person who was likely to have been included in the list of names, and possibly two, would have had numbers that were different from what’s listed. That’s not nothing.

I notice that the unredacted names in the June 10 memo are arranged alphabetically, in which case Larry Shub and Ron Weissenberger would be out of order if we placed them where the redactions are.

You have an excellent eye for detail. That’s another reason that I’m not 100% sure about those two. However, bear in mind that the memo came from FBI Headquarters. I wouldn’t put it past them to type the memo that way on purpose to deceive us in the event a member of the public (e.g., yours truly) should ever question their tactics. But if Larry Shub and Ron Weissenberger weren’t among the redacted names, Mary Helen Nicholas’s name still fits perfectly between Thomas Foglesong and Jerry Rupe. I’m convinced that her name is hidden under one of those black marks.

Did you say that you’re finding other FBI records that would fall under this same tactic?

So far, I’ve found several examples in which I believe the FBI redacted a person’s name if it didn’t fit their made-up alphabetical system.

Take this one, for example.

Declassified FBI memo dated July 26, 1965, concerning potential bombing suspect John Keehan and an attempted bombing at Judo and Karate Center in Chicago.
Click on image for a closer view

This is a case from 1965 in which two guys were arrested for the attempted bombing of the Chicago Judo and Karate Center in Chicago’s south side. Apparently, they both had been instructors there and they felt the owner at that time owed them money. One of the suspect’s names, John Keehan, is unredacted, but his accomplice’s name, Doug Dwyer, whose name I found in an old news article, is. You see that 6 in the upper righthand corner? Keehan’s K would have gotten a 6 in their made-up alphabetical system. Dwyer’s name, which would have been assigned a 3 in their made-up system, doesn’t fit. I think that’s why they redacted his name.

Here’s another example.

Scanned FBI letter dated March 17, 1971, acknowledging a report of obscene threatening postcards sent to Senator Gaylord Nelson.
Click on image for a closer view

This has to do with a case involving former Senator Gaylord Nelson, of Wisconsin. Someone had sent an obscene postcard to Senator Nelson and his administrative assistant forwarded it to the FBI. The administrative assistant’s name was redacted. So was the name of the person who’d sent the postcard. He’d sent that same postcard to several other legislators as well. Do you see the 7 and 8 in the upper righthand corner? The 8 would apply to Senator Nelson’s N in their made-up system. But the 7 doesn’t apply to either of the redacted names. It doesn’t apply to Nelson’s administrative assistant, William Cherkasky, who would have been assigned a 2 under their made-up system. And it doesn’t apply to the obscene postcard sender, whose last name, which starts with an “Sh,” would have received a 9. (I think he may have had mental health issues, which is why I won’t be sharing his name with you.) So, again, I think that his name and Cherkasky’s name were redacted because they didn’t fit the FBI’s made-up system.

Here’s another example from the same case.

FBI Latent Fingerprint Section report dated March 16, 1971, regarding fingerprints developed on four postal cards in an extortion case.
Click on image for a closer view

Here we have another legislator, former Congressman Wilbur Mills, of Arkansas, who received the same obscene postcard. Note the 7 in the righthand corner, which would be consistent with Mills’ M. The postcard writer’s name is redacted. Peeking out of the redaction is a circle in front of his last name, which, again, we know starts with the letters “Sh.” Where’s that guy’s 9 in the upper righthand corner?

I’ve also found an example in which I was able to figure out the name that had been redacted simply by reading through the rest of the document.

Redacted 1964 FBI memorandum summarizing Anthony Thomas Ulasewicz’s military service and background records.
Click on image for a closer view
Scanned biographical record listing a man's hair, eyes, complexion, build, education, occupations, addresses, relatives, and Social Security number, with personal details redacted.
Click on image for a closer view
Redacted FBI memorandum dated September 29, 1969, addressed to the director and concerning an FBI source in New York.
Click on image for a closer view

Anthony Ulasewicz was a law enforcement officer with the New York Police Department who later became involved in the Watergate scandal because of his specialization in security and intelligence-gathering. Two FBI reports that focus on him as the main topic, one from 1964 and another from 1969, has had its subject redacted. Both records have been assigned two numbers: 10 and 3. Because both records are discussing Anthony Ulasewicz, and only Anthony Ulasewicz, that’s the name that I believe has been redacted from the subject line. The first letter of his last name has a circle in the first paragraph of the April 1964 document.

I think they redacted Anthony Ulasewicz’ name from the subject because they couldn’t explain the 3. The 10 fits their made-up system, but not the 3.

Finally, let’s talk about Wernher von Braun, the former Nazi rocket engineer who was brought over to the United States after WWII through Operation Paperclip and who later went on to high posts at NASA. Records from his file are all over the map as far as the numbers in the righthand corner. But you know what? From what I can tell, the only time his name isn’t redacted is when A) there isn’t a number in the righthand corner, or B) there’s an 11 in the righthand corner, which would fit their made-up system. For the other numbers (2, 3, 4, 7, 8, and 9), the subject line has been redacted. We know his name must be somewhere on those documents because they’re in his file. I get it—von Braun has a LOT of redactions on his records and sometimes the subject line is a topic that isn’t his name. The blackness of those redactions makes it impossible to know if his name is there or not. But, at least for some of his records with numbers other than 11 in the upper righthand corner, I believe they redacted the subject line because it doesn’t fit the FBI’s made-up system.

Redacted FBI memorandum dated March 5, 1963, from the Richmond SAC to the Pittsburgh SAC, listing enclosed letters and newspaper articles.
I believe Wernher von Braun’s name is redacted here because his name doesn’t fit the 2-1 notation in the FBI’s made-up system; click on link for a closer view
Redacted FBI office memorandum dated August 20, 1958, marked “Espionage – X,” with handwritten annotations and classification stamps.
I believe Wernher von Braun’s name is redacted here because his name doesn’t fit the 3-1 notation in the FBI’s made-up system; click on link for a closer view
Redacted United States Government office memorandum dated October 27, 1958, concerning the reactivation of Nazi activities and internal security in Germany.
Wernher von Braun’s name isn’t in the subject line and no letters are circled. Although the 9-1 notation would be appropriate for the word “Reactivation,” it isn’t circled. Of all the words in the subject line, I would think that the word Nazi would have been circled. If so, the 9-1 doesn’t apply to the letter N in the FBI’s made-up system. I believe this document shows that the numbers in the righthand corner and the circled letters are unrelated. Click on image for a closer view.
Redacted FBI air mail memorandum dated November 12, 1959, concerning Wernher von Braun and a possible kidnapping or sabotage threat.
Wernher von Braun’s name is visible, though I don’t believe it’s circled here. Instead, the word sabotage has the circle. Nevertheless, the number in the righthand corner is an 11, which fits von Braun’s name but it doesn’t fit the word sabotage, which would be a 9. I believe this is another document that shows that the numbers in the righthand corner and the circled letters are unrelated. Click on image for a closer view.

What do you hope to do with this info?

I’ll continue tracking the outliers of their made-up system, be they accidentally overlooked or cleverly concealed. (Regarding the latter, I also think they sometimes redacted the numbers instead of the names or, if it was an original record, they erased them. I’ve seen lots of black marks, tape outlines, and eraser marks in that general vicinity.) If anyone from the FBI should challenge me and my hypothesis, I’ll be able to whip out my evidence and say something like “See? SEE?” Then we’ll have a good laugh, hug it out, and they’ll open up and tell me everything.

No, seriously, if there’s something major to report to you, I’ll report it. Otherwise, I think we’ve ventured far enough into this weedy thicket and can move on to more riveting topics concerning Ron Tammen from here on out.

Before we do though, here are just a few of the many more examples that I’ve been finding of numbers that should or should not have been in the upper righthand corners under the FBI’s made-up system but were accidentally overlooked. (These are in addition to the accidentally overlooked outliers that I reported in a prior post.)

August 18, 1960

Scanned FBI memorandum dated August 18, 1960, concerning an investigation of Eligio Cabel Suri Goicoechea and related individuals.
Circled names: Caleb/Suri/Goicoechea
Numbers in righthand corner: 7-, 8-, 9-, 10-
What they overlooked: Where are the 2 for Caleb and the 4 for Goicoechea?
Why the 7, 8, and 9?

November 1, 1960

Declassified 1960 U.S. government memorandum regarding CIA contact with Cuban source Ana Rosa Guerra Santamarina.
Circled names: Guerra/Santana
Numbers in righthand corner: 4-1, 10-1
What they overlooked: Santana should get a 9, not a 10

March 4, 1964

Declassified CIA telegram from March 1964 concerning French counterespionage agents Jean Souetre, Michel Roux, and Michel Mertz, covered in handwritten annotations.
Circled names: Souetre/Roux/Mertz
Numbers in righthand corner: 10-
What they overlooked: Where are the 9 for Roux and the 7 for Mertz?

November 14, 1967

Declassified FBI memorandum dated November 14, 1967, concerning electronic surveillance records and investigative subjects, with handwritten annotations.
Circled names: Lands/Link/Richardson
Numbers in righthand corner: 6, 9, 10
What they overlooked: Why the 10?

August 24, 1971

Declassified FBI report cover sheet from the San Francisco office, dated September 2, 1971, with redacted fields and handwritten annotations.
Circled name: Treuhaft
Numbers in righthand corner: 10, 7-
What they overlooked: Why the 7?

May 9, 1972

Scanned FBI teletype memorandum dated May 15, 1972, concerning Meyer Lansky, with handwritten annotations and redacted sections.
Circled name: Lansky
Numbers in righthand corner (w/o enclosures): 6, 10
What they overlooked: Why the 10?

July 27, 1972

Scanned FBI memo dated July 27, 1972, concerning victims of an extortion case, with handwritten annotations and redactions.
Circled names: Redacted/Mandel/O’Brien/Schaefer/Bayh/
Albert/Agnew/Nixon/Kennedy/Humphrey/McGovern/Brezhnev
Number in righthand corner: 7-1
What they overlooked: The 7 works for Mandel and McGovern but no one else.
Where are the rest of the numbers?

September 24, 1973

Scanned FBI report dated September 24, 1973, about a confrontation between United Farm Workers and Teamsters in Kern County, California.
Circled names: Confrontation/United/Teamsters
Numbers in righthand corner: 11, 10
What they overlooked: Where’s the 3 for Confrontation?

Has your thinking changed about who the numbers in the righthand corner might have referred to?

I’m still not sure. I’m now wondering if the numbers might refer to people who represented key sections or units under the Department of Justice (DOJ). Such sections may include Organized Crime, Fraud, Narcotic and Dangerous Drugs, and Internal Security. Other numbers may refer to the attorney general, the deputy attorney general, and the head of the Criminal Division.

I look at it this way: the DOJ oversees the FBI, and the lawyers and other staffers in the DOJ probably wouldn’t mind being kept in the loop on some of the FBI’s bigger cases, including certain missing person cases. For topics such as Watergate and Kent State, both of which had lengthy lists of numbers in the upper righthand corner, especially at the beginning, I can imagine a high-up FBI staffer thinking that the more DOJ administrators who were cc’d, the merrier. If the numbers do refer to the DOJ, then perhaps it was the DOJ who instructed the FBI to hide their meaning from pesky FOIA requesters. If the FBI is just following orders from on high, it might explain why they’d feel empowered to pull such stunts as withholding records and redacting information that should be made public. After all, who’s going to press charges? Someone’s boss’s boss’s boss at the DOJ, the nation’s top law enforcement agency, who told them to do it? But it’s just a guess.

I do need to update you on something.

What?

You know my FOIA request to the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) regarding their proactive review project for the missing person records I obtained this past summer? If you don’t remember, you can read more about it here: https://ronaldtammen.com/2026/10/05/more-foia-follies/.

On October 6, 2026, I emailed the Office of Government Information Services (OGIS), which helps mediate FOIA requests, including those pertaining to NARA. I’d briefed them on the situation and asked for their assistance to my FOIA request in four ways:

1) Determine how the same FOIA office can first provide an estimate of 10 working days for a FOIA response, and, shortly thereafter, push that estimate back to 58 months with no further explanation.

2) Determine why my FOIA request was labeled “complex” when there was no mention of that label in their September 16 letter.

3) Determine who the “office separate from our office” is that is ostensibly processing my request.

4) Review the 58-month time estimate to determine how it can be revised to a more reasonable timeframe.

I heard back from OGIS on November 4. Here’s the letter they sent me, in which they let me know that there is very little that they can do to assist me with my case. The only thing they could do was reach out to NARA’s FOIA Office, who told them that they’d be responding to my October 6 email.

Official letter from the Office of Government Information Services responding to a pending FOIA request and explaining processing delays at the National Archives.
Click on image for a closer view

I’ll let you know as soon as I hear from them. By the way, I told NARA about this blog in an earlier email, and they know you’re interested in this case. I’m pretty sure that the FBI knows too.

Finally, because no write-up about May 4, 1970, would be complete without including an homage to Neil Young’s “Ohio,” here’s a moving rendition performed by the Kent State University Chorale in 2020. This virtual performance was requested by Neil Young after he viewed their performance of “Find the Cost of Freedom.” It was arranged by KSU choral alumna Brandy Kay Riha. Amazing.

Sincere thanks to The Black Vault, the Mary Ferrell Foundation the National Archives, and the FBI Vault for making these records available.

Happy Halloween! Here are the top ten scariest things that have happened to me since I’ve started researching Ron Tammen’s disappearance

A black and white photograph of a skeleton with its mouth open, positioned against a backdrop of foliage, raising one hand to its head.
Photo by Sabina Music Rich on Unsplash

Happy Halloween, Good Man readers! For the past several days, I’ve been writing a post having to do with my latest rabbit hole, namely, how the FBI has been doctoring its records to mislead the public. But then I started noticing an uptick in new visitors on account of it being Halloween and all. As you know, Halloween is the time of year when people tend to think of Ron Tammen.

So I’m pulling a switcheroo. Instead of posting my latest findings that my diehard readers will surely love, although I’m not sure about anyone else, I’m going to discuss a more relatable topic for all of us. I’m going to tell you the top ten scariest things that have happened to me in my 16 years of researching Ron Tammen’s disappearance. (Note to diehards: we’ll discuss more of the FBI’s antics another day. I promise.)

Here’s my top ten list, starting with 10 and ending with numero uno. Some of these you probably know about. Others I’ve kept to myself, until now:

10. The minute I realized that St. Clair Switzer, Ron Tammen’s psychology professor, was mentioned on a CIA document as a potential consultant for Project Artichoke

Yeah, this scary realization kicked off the whole shebang regarding my theory of what happened to Ron Tammen. Because, if Ron Tammen’s psychology professor was working with the CIA, then they did it. They took him. I’m sorry, but they did. And you can just imagine how scary it was to realize that the person I’ve been inquiring about was taken by the CIA. With every FOIA request I’ve sent them, I’ve wondered if I was becoming a household name to our friends in the intelligence community. So that’s kinda creepy.

9. When I discovered the connection between Ron Tammen and James McCord

For 19 years, James McCord, of Watergate fame, had been employed by the CIA’s Office of Security, which oversaw Project Artichoke. When I discovered that he and Ron shared a stamp combination on their FBI records (ST-102, REC-19), it freaked me out. No, seriously. It was late at night and I remember sitting in my big comfy chair and looking out the window, as if someone out there knew what I’d just discovered. I think that’s when I implemented our current “don’t open the door for anyone unless you’re expecting them” policy. To date, it has proven to be a good strategy. I have one exception: I will open the door when my neighbor pops by with homegrown tomatoes. I have gotten to know his knock. Otherwise, if you’re not dropping off homegrown tomatoes, I’m not home.

8. When I learned that a French terrorist who’d been suspected of assassinating JFK has FBI records that look like Ron’s

The French terrorist I’m talking about is Jean René Souètre, a man I’d heard had been potentially linked to the JFK assassination. I didn’t even know his name at first. On a whim, again, late at night, I figured out what it was and then looked him up on the Mary Ferrell Foundation website to see what his FBI records looked like. According to his records, he couldn’t have killed JFK, but the FBI had definitely been interested in finding out if he was anywhere near Dallas on November 22, 1963. When I saw all of the 10s on his records, just like Ron’s 10s, I freaked out again. I think that may have been the moment I thought, did the FBI consider Ron an assassin, just like Jean René Souètre? If so, he would’ve been government-sanctioned since, according to the FBI, he’d never been arrested. That’s…um…really scary.

7. The time in 2013 when some man who lived in the Bronx called my cell and I thought it might be Ron

In 2013, I was still living in D.C., and I was heavy into making phone calls to Ron’s family and friends. One Saturday morning, someone whose name had things in common with Ron’s name called my cell but he didn’t leave a message. I won’t tell you his last name, but his first name was John—Ron’s brother’s name—and his middle initial was H. I don’t know why, but I thought, what if it’s Ron? After all, I’d been emailing my cell number to God and everyone. What if one of those people—his brother John perhaps—forwarded it to Ron. I remember working myself up into a little frenzy. Then I got scared. What if he yells at me? What if he tells me to butt out and to stop calling everyone and to let him live his life? When I called him back later that day, he sounded elderly, which also tracked. Acting as nonchalant as possible, I asked him if he had called me earlier in the day. Mind you, that was a bizarre thing for me to do. I never call strangers who misdial my number, let alone doing so hours later. But this time was different. His response was just as weird. “Oh, I think the kids were playing with my phone.” As you diehards know, I now think that Ron had already died by that time—sometime between 2002, when the FBI expunged his fingerprints because of a conflict with the Privacy Act, and 2010, when the FBI sent me Ron’s missing person records without seeking third-party authorization. But it would have been so cool if it was Ron. And also kind of scary.

6. When I realized that the FBI had been lying to the Butler County cold case detective about not knowing what happened to Ron’s fingerprints

It’s one thing for the FBI to lie to me, which it does all the time. But when the FBI lies to a member of law enforcement, someone in a profession with whom the FBI is ostensibly in a working partnership, that’s saying something. When Butler County’s cold case detective, Frank Smith, contacted the FBI in 2008 seeking Ron’s fingerprints, they pretended not to know anything. Frank knew that they’d had his fingerprints at one time because he saw the fingerprint notations on one of his missing person documents. But when he reached out to them, they merely told him that they’d looked everywhere and couldn’t find them. They gave him no other info. They didn’t tell him that the fingerprints had been expunged in 2002 and they certainly didn’t tell him that they were permitted to expunge them 30 years early due to Record Schedule N1-065-88-3 item 1A, which means that they did so based on a court order or a conflict with the Privacy Act of 1974. (I later narrowed it down to the latter.) Why would the FBI lie to a cold case detective? Because he was investigating something that’s bigger than anyone knows. And now I’ve picked up the baton, which is…you guessed it…scary.

5. Podcasts

You all know I’m an introvert, right? My comfort zone is sitting in front of the fire writing, which is something I happen to be doing at the moment. What’s scary is sitting in front of a Zoom camera for an hour or two trying to reel off the specifics of my 16 years of Ron Tammen research without forgetting anything important. Names, dates, and places are my phobias. Brain freeze is my bogeyman. What’s the lady’s name who lived in Seven Mile who had a guy show up on her doorstep late at night on April 19, 1953? Oh, right, Clara Spivey! What was the little town where H.H. Stephenson saw a guy who looked like Ron eating with several other young men? Of course, Wellsville, NY! What’s the name of the Air Force base near San Antonio where Louis Jolyon West was stationed during a time I believe he was in communication with Ron Tammen’s psychology professor, St. Clair Switzer? It’s Lackland Air Force Base, Jenny. Don’t forget!

I’m grateful to the podcasters, and I’ve enjoyed every interview I’ve done. It was awesome talking with them. Also, I’m sure I will happily accept future invitations to talk about Ron Tammen to get the word out about his story. But that doesn’t mean I won’t be in a subdued state of panic leading up to and during our conversation. Scary, but still worth it.

4. Every time I place a phone call to a potentially hostile source

If you think talking to nice podcasters is scary for an introvert, imagine talking to people who, for whatever reason, don’t want to talk to you about Ron Tammen or various related subjects. These are the hostiles, the people who say things like “Hey, what’s all this about??” or “I think we’re done here!” and hang up on you. They’re the ones who block you after you’ve left a well-meaning message hoping for a sit-down. Most of the people I’ve spoken with have been wonderfully helpful and they, too, are interested in seeking the truth about Ron. But there are others who want nothing to do with me or my project. I can’t imagine pulling one of those 60 Minutes Mike Wallace in-person pop-ins to someone who won’t pick up their phone. That, my friends, is not in my DNA and I’ve had zero training in it. I suppose I’ve gotten a little crustier on the exterior after starting this project, and I’ve made some calls in which I was expecting some pushback but instead had a delightful convo. Let’s put these in the scary, but worth it category as well.

3. Every time my computer acts up

To be sure, I’m no computer whiz. I’ve been known to press the wrong key or to misplace a file from time to time. But I’m also not a beginner. I know…um…things about computers. When one of those AI chat bubbles pops up in the bottom right corner of my screen asking me if I want more info, I will sometimes ask for more info. If I accidentally click on a bad link that has compromised my bank card, I know to jump on my bank’s web page lickety split and cancel that card asap. If MS Word is acting all wonky, I remember to turn off my computer and turn it back on again, without anyone telling me to. I guess you could call me semi-literate. But after I started conducting research into Ron Tammen, it seems that computer problems have happened more frequently to me. One time I lost an entire email conversation with someone from the FBI and I don’t remember hitting the delete key. Maybe this isn’t fair, but every time something happens—every downage, every outage, every blank screen, every lost file, every lost conversation—is, in my mind, courtesy of the FBI or CIA sabotaging my research. That never fails to make me shudder in fear.

2. When I was on my walk-run this past summer

I’ve been living with this secret since this past July or so. One day, while I was on my walk-run, I felt something sting me in my lower right back. It felt like a bee or something and it hurt really bad. But I didn’t see any insects flying away afterward. When I got home, I took a look at it, and there wasn’t just one bite. There were six large bumps and, get this, they were shaped in an arrow formation. I kid you not.  Do you know what else? They’re still there. They’re smaller and lighter and I think they’ll go away at some point, but this was no ordinary insect bite. I’ve told people that I thought I may have been hit by a poison dart gun, which was 95% just joking and 5% OMG, what if? I didn’t feel woozy or weird after it happened. It just hurt for a long time. Nevertheless, I’ve changed my walk-run route, and that information will remain classified.

1. When I found out that a retired special agent for the FBI lives really close to me

One day, I was attempting to locate some retired special agents from the FBI to fill me in on their experiences. I wanted operational details. So, imagine my astonishment when I located one of the men and found that he lived mere blocks from me. I wrote him a letter. I’m sure he was surprised to hear from me as well. I won’t tell you his name. I won’t say if we met or not, but I will say this: he knows who I am, he knows what I’m doing, and he knows where I live, which is super close to him. So yeah…the homegrown tomatoes policy still applies.

Two more reasons to believe that Ron’s ‘Hac’ notations are FBI shorthand for Howard Hughes

Historic sepia-toned photograph of a village featuring a church with a tall spire, surrounded by homes and trees, taken from a distance.
By Carleton, C. G. — Photographer – Church and houses in Waterville, Maine — Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=7186590

Greetings! I’m pulling a Saturday pop-in to tell you about two more ‘Hac’ records I found.

First, let’s do a quick tally of the other Hacs we’ve found in the top righthand corner of various FBI records:

–Two Hacs can be found on records from July 1973 concerning Hank Greenspun, publisher of the Las Vegas Sun,

FBI document dated July 13, 1973, discussing an alleged planned burglary of Las Vegas publisher Henry Greenspun's office, including references to related interviews and legal considerations.
Click on image for a closer view
A typed letter from the FBI Director regarding an alleged planned burglary of Henry Greenspun's office, including instructions for interviewing relevant individuals and details about handling the investigation.
Click on image for a closer view

–One 1971 record on the New England chapter of the Committee for Non-Violent Action (CNVA) has a Hac plus the initials “sd” written nearby,

Document detailing the New England Committee for Non-Violent Action (NECNVA), outlining its purpose as a non-partisan pacifist organization formed to promote non-violent resistance against tyranny and foreign invasion, headquartered in Voluntown, Connecticut.
Click on image for a closer view

–Ten pages of Ron Tammen’s missing person records have the Hac notation in the top righthand corner.

A letter from the United States Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation, dated October 30, 1961, regarding a missing person notice for Ronald Henry Tammen, Jr. The letter is addressed to Marjorie J. Tammen and discusses the status of the missing person case.
Click on image for a closer view; this is just one of Ron’s 10 pages with a Hac on it

That makes 13 Hacs so far, with Ron’s records carrying the lion’s share of them. As we’ve discussed, my current theory is that Hac stands for Hughes Aircraft Company, and, therefore, could be the FBI’s shorthand for Howard Hughes.

Here’s why I believe Howard Hughes was the noteworthy person that everyone with a Hac had in common:

Howard Hughes and Hank Greenspun

Hank Greenspun had considered himself a friend of Howard Hughes, even though he, like Hughes’ right-hand man Robert Maheu, had never seen him face-to-face. In 1966, Hank had encouraged Howard to move to Las Vegas and invest in properties there. In 1967, Hank had agreed to sell Howard his TV station, KLAS, so that Howard could watch his favorite movies all night long when all the other stations in the area had signed off, which is something TV stations did back then. Ralph Witte, who is also discussed in the two Hac memos, was head of security for Howard Hughes’ Summa operation, formerly Hughes Tool Company. He was one of Howard’s top men. And let’s not forget that the two Hac documents were about an attempted burglary of Greenspun’s safe, which contained hundreds of memos between Howard Hughes and Robert Maheu. Hank Greenspun’s connection with Howard Hughes is rock solid and crystal clear.

Howard Hughes and the CNVA

Howard Hughes was ardently opposed to underground nuclear testing, especially if the nuclear testing was happening in his vicinity. Not only did he detest how the underground bombs being set off at the Nevada Proving Grounds caused his Desert Inn penthouse to shake and sway, but he feared what the radiation was doing to the water. (Howard was right to be concerned, by the way.) The CNVA was the first organization to protest underground nuclear testing at Base Camp Mercury, 65 miles from Las Vegas, in 1957. They were so well known for their creative, peaceful protests, other groups, including Greenpeace, modeled their protests after the CNVA’s tactics. In 1974, Robert Maheu testified that John Meier, one of Hughes’ employees, “was originally hired as part of a Hughes’ scheme to aid groups protesting atomic bomb testing [in] late 1966. Hughes called him to outline a plan to assign ‘somebody with a scientific background’ to assist the various ban-the-bomb groups.” Although the CNVA wasn’t specified, I think there’s a pretty good chance that it was one of those groups.

Howard Hughes and Ron Tammen

I’m still trying to figure out how Ron Tammen would have had a connection with Howard Hughes. My current theory is that Hughes Aircraft Company may have served as a cover for Ron, since that operation frequently worked in cahoots with the CIA. I also think that Robert Maheu, who had a close relationship with the CIA’s Office of Security since 1954, was how Ron would have entered the Hughes orbit.

OK, now let’s talk about the other two records I’ve found with Hacs on them.

Howard Hughes and Larry O’Brien (June 17, 1972)

Faded document with header indicating a report from the Secret Service, dated June 17, 1972, discussing security issues related to the Democratic National Committee and an incident involving five Cubans arrested.
Click on image for a closer view
A document page with text discussing an individual named Frank Fiorini, who is described as a former anti-Castro activist and adventurer, including notes on related incidents and requests for further information.
Click on image for a closer view

The first new Hac is on a record dated June 17, 1972, the day of the Watergate break-in. It’s a teletype from the FBI’s Miami Field Office to the Washington Field Office as well as Acting FBI Director L. Patrick Gray and the Domestic Intelligence Division. The teletype has to do with Larry O’Brien, then-chair of the Democratic National Committee (DNC). Miami told Washington that they had a source who said that five burglars had been arrested in the office of Philip Seib, Larry’s assistant, attempting to burglarize materials there. Even though the burglars were in Seib’s office, I’m sure everyone’s antennae went up when they saw Larry’s name in the teletype. (If you think it’s weird that the guys in Miami are informing the Washington Field Office, the office of origin for Watergate, about who was arrested in what office, you’re in good company. I’ll have more to say about this memo in a later post.)

OK, so I need to come clean about something. We’ve actually seen this teletype before. However, when I showed it to you the first time, I was discussing how similar the “H” looked to the H in Ron’s Hacs. The letters are extremely light, and not as easy to read as Ron’s bold Hacs. But the word appeared to be longer—at least five or six letters. I thought it may have been someone’s name, possibly the same person who wrote the letters H-a-c at the top of Ron’s and Hank’s documents. (I hadn’t discovered the CNVA document yet.)

I now believe that the June 17, 1972, teletype has a Hac too, followed by two initials, similar to the initials “sd” that follow the Hac on the CNVA document. Heck, the initials might even be “sd” on Larry O’Brien’s document too.

If this is indeed another Hac sighting, and if Hac is indeed shorthand for Howard Hughes, then it makes total sense that someone would write those letters on this teletype. Larry O’Brien had an incredibly strong connection to Howard Hughes. He’d been hired to serve as Hughes’ lobbyist in Washington, D.C., influencing senators and tweaking proposed legislation for Howard’s sole benefit, before he became chair of the DNC. In fact, according to Michael Drosnin, author of the book Citizen Hughes, O’Brien was still working for Hughes while he was chair of the DNC, since the latter was an unpaid position. (Apparently, that’s no longer true—the latest figure I’ve seen that the DNC chair earns is $350K/year.) This arrangement likely drove Richard Nixon crazy. Picture it like this: here was the chair of the DNC, whose primary goal was to defeat Richard Nixon in the 1972 election, likely having full knowledge about the $100,000 in bribe money that Hughes had paid to Nixon through Nixon’s buddy in Miami, Bebe Rebozo. Nixon’s most overriding fear was that the $100K bribe would become public knowledge, destroying his chances for reelection. No wonder Liddy, Hunt, and the rest of the Watergate Seven had tried to bug O’Brien’s office. So, again, the Howard Hughes connection to Larry O’Brien is crystal clear.

Let’s move on to the second new Hac. When I stumbled onto this one, let’s just say that the subject’s ties to Howard Hughes were less than clear to me. In fact, I thought this person’s pursuits were so different from Howard Hughes’ priorities, I was going to have to walk away from my theory that their paths had ever crossed. Even worse, I was going to have to report back to you that our theory about our favorite reclusive billionaire had officially been shred into a billion tiny pieces.

Well, good news, guys. I’m happy to report that the theory is still intact.

Howard Hughes and Susan Heiligman Frank (Sept. 14, 1972)

FBI memorandum dated September 14, 1972, regarding Susan Heilgman Frank and Richard Cyril Frank, detailing their connections with various organizations and individuals.
Click on image for a closer view

Susan Heiligman Frank and her husband Richard Cyril Frank were being closely watched by the FBI for quite some time. The FBI was always putting out feelers for Susan and Richard, trying to find out what they were up to and using whatever means they deemed necessary: field offices and LEGATS, informants, electronic surveillance, you name it. The reason for the FBI’s ongoing interest in the Franks was their former membership in the U.S. communist party, as well as their infatuation with the People’s Republic of China. They were staunch advocates for the Chinese people and seemed to have friends in high places over there.

So imagine my surprise when I found the above memo with some familiar notations.

First, I saw the FD-217 (followed by an NY)

Close-up of handwritten text showing the letters 'fd-213N' in blue ink on a beige background.

Then, I noticed the 10-2.

A handwritten note displaying the number '10.2' in blue ink on a light background.

Then I saw the Hac.

A handwritten signature in blue ink on a light-colored background.

What’s weird is that these notations were misplaced. They’re in the left margin of the memo instead of the upper righthand corner. I ignored the other notations for the moment and focused on the Hac. There was no question about it. That was a Hac, all right.

I don’t know much about Susan Frank—only what the FBI has written about her, which isn’t very flattering. Nevertheless, I couldn’t see any connection whatsoever with Howard Hughes. She wasn’t his type, to put it mildly. When I saw the Hac, I was bummed. I walked away for a while. I think I poured myself a glass of kombucha. There may have been chips and salsa involved as well.

A few days later, I found another memo.

“Hold on,” said I. “I guess she was his type after all.”

On October 15, 1968, the New York City Field Office had reported that the FBI’s Paris LEGAT had somehow gotten their hands on Susan’s address book when she was visiting the City of Lights. (See what I mean about her being watched constantly? Girlfriend couldn’t even take a nice European vacay without having some Parisian intelligence officer rifling through her purse and stealing her stuff.)

The New York office flagged two names in her address book that they felt J. Edgar Hoover should know about ASAP.  One guy was an Iranian national who might be with the KGB. That one didn’t interest me. The name that did interest me was David A. Robinson. And the reason that David A. Robinson interested me was because they added this comment to his entry:

“Above the name of ROBINSON was a notation “HUGHES’ friend…”

A confidential memorandum dated October 15, 1968, addressed to the FBI Director, discussing Susan Heiligman Frank. Includes references to translation requests, addresses, and individuals associated with Newark and Boston during August 1968.
Click on image for a closer view

Hughes’ friend? There’s only one Hughes who could have drawn that kind of attention from the FBI at that time. It had to be Howard.

My next question was: who was this David A. Robinson and how did he become friends with Howard Hughes? Howard Hughes didn’t have “friends,” so to speak, at least not then. From the books I’d been reading about Howard Hughes, I’d venture to say that he had zero friends at that point in time. Jean Peters had divorced him by then because she never saw the guy. Even if they happened to be in the same building, which wasn’t often, he wouldn’t let her into his room. He was a recluse, for goodness’ sake. Recluses, as a rule, don’t have friends.

I delved more into David A. Robinson.

David A. Robinson was born in Tianjin, China in 1925. His father, Arthur, had moved to China in 1913 and served as a secretary for the YMCA there for 13 years. In 1926, when David was about 6 months old, Arthur and his family moved back to the United States, but not for long. Three years later, David’s parents both became commissioned missionaries based in China, where the family remained until around 1937.

When Susan Frank met David Robinson, he was living in Wellesley, Massachusetts. A graduate of Yale Divinity School, he was a respected minister with the Boston Theological Institute, working to improve relations with China. One of his key advocacy issues was for China to become part of the United Nations. I understood why David Robinson’s name would turn up in Susan Frank’s address book. What I couldn’t understand was how David Robinson managed to strike up a friendship with Howard Hughes.

I needed to dig a little deeper into David A. Robinson’s family history. With all the talk about China, I needed to develop a better understanding of where David’s roots were. Who did Arthur and the fam visit over the holidays or during family reunions? With whom did David Robinson hang?

As it turns out, David’s roots were in Waterville, Maine, a picturesque town on the banks of the Kennebec River. Canoeing was huge there and maybe still is, though I’m sure kayaks and paddle boards have taken over. Many French-Canadians settled there.

Do you know who else grew up in Waterville, Maine? Robert Maheu. Both the Robinsons and Maheus were well-established in Waterville. You could say they were the OGs of the Watervillians.

Don’t get me wrong. David Robinson and Robert Maheu weren’t classmates or anything like that. David had spent a large chunk of his formative years in China and Robert’s and David’s ages don’t match up either. Robert Maheu was born in 1917, so he was 8 years older than David Robinson. Also, when the Robinsons moved back to the states in 1937, they were living in Auburndale, Massachusetts, about three hours from Waterville. Still, both families were well connected in the community. Maheu’s father Ephrem owned a carbonated-beverage bottling company called Elm City Bottling that he operated in a barn behind the local grocery store that he also ran from 1916 until his death in 1954. Ephrem Maheu also dabbled in politics, having served as an alderman for several terms as well as a state legislator for two terms.

As for David Robinson’s grandparents, Increase and Elizabeth Robinson, they were also stalwarts of Waterville. Increase worked as a contractor and builder in town and later as an insurance agent. They were also active in the Congregational Church. After Increase died in 1916, his wife Lizzie left Waterville to live with a daughter. But Arthur maintained a close relationship with Waterville even after his parents were no longer there. A 1906 graduate of Colby College, whose campus is in downtown Waterville, he kept in close contact with his alma mater. He was a big deal in the community, often returning to give talks about his work in China at college commencements and church gatherings. He even collected donations from the citizens of Waterville for famine relief in China. As a young man, Robert Maheu would have been reading about Waterville’s local hero in the newspaper, the Morning Sentinel. Likewise, I’m sure Arthur and David would have stopped into Ephrem’s store, where Robert was known to help out, for an orange soda during one of their visits. After WWII, Robert Maheu and his wife moved back to Waterville for a little while to help her recover from a terrible bout with tuberculosis. Maheu at that time was still with the FBI, and J. Edgar Hoover allowed him to open up an FBI Field Office in Waterville, Maine, of all places.

With Robert Maheu being the extrovert that he was, I’m certain that Robert Maheu knew David A. Robinson and even called him a friend. Likewise, I’m sure David Robinson told Susan Frank about his friendship with Robert Maheu, who, during the 1950s and ‘60s, was the alter-ego of Howard Hughes. That would make the notation in her address book, “Hughes’ friend,” understandable.

I think we’ll stop here for now. If you ever find yourself in Waterville, Maine, be sure to visit Pine Grove Cemetery, where Arthur and his siblings are all buried in the family plot, in addition to Increase and Lizzie. Then make the short trip to Saint Francis Catholic Cemetery, where Robert Maheu, Maheu’s wife Yvette, and Maheu’s parents Ephrem and Christine are buried.

Rev. David Arthur Robinson died on August 13, 2007, in Brooklyn, NY. Unfortunately, I’m unable to determine the location of his remains.

Sincere thanks to The Black Vault, the Mary Ferrell Foundation the National Archives, and the FBI Vault for making these records available.

More FOIA follies: Someone has been mysteriously pushing buttons regarding my 2022 FOIA request to NARA. Gosh, who could it be?

Can we talk a little more about my trip to the National Archives (NARA) this past summer? As you may recall, I’d contacted NARA in June, telling them that I’d be visiting them on the 14th of August in hopes of reviewing the FBI missing person records from a FOIA request I’d submitted back in 2022. The records I’d be reviewing had been transferred from the FBI to NARA in 2017, and they covered missing person cases from 1947 through 1980. My original FOIA request had been to review the full list of records, which totaled 87, but, because I’d been informed that they were experiencing an eight-year backlog, I whittled that number down to 18. Put simply (and kind of morbidly), I wanted to see them before I died, so I scaled back my request.

In my June email, I said that, if they happened to process any more of the missing person records after they’d completed processing my 18, I’d like to see those too. They let me know that they had, and those records would also be set aside for me to review. I was a little taken aback by their response—Why would they keep processing the missing person records after they completed my request?, I wondered—but I took it as good news. 

I arrived on August 14, and found that all the records except one—a total of 86—were ready for viewing, with the final 20 having been processed after our conversation in June. Interestingly, it had taken them two years to process my 18 records but only two months to process the last 20. What they handed me was far beyond the scope of my request and way ahead of schedule.

Don’t get me wrong—I was grateful, but I was growing a little suspicious.

“How often does a FOIA rep give a person more than what they’ve asked for?” I asked myself. 

“This is NARA we’re talking about,” I answered. “NARA employs helpful people who believe in FOIA.”

I agreed and got to the task of reviewing the digitized records. 

I noticed that two different FOIA numbers had been assigned to the missing person case files. Eighteen envelopes had my FOIA number on them, which was RD 67625. The rest of the envelopes were labeled RD 87542, a number that was a lot higher than my FOIA number—by nearly 20,000. I could be wrong about this, but if NARA assigns its FOIA numbers in consecutive order, which seems like a logical thing for them to do, RD 87542 had been submitted 19,917 submissions after mine.

Image displaying a notice screened by NARA (RF) on August 14, 2024, including a FOIA number RD 67625.
This is my FOIA request number
Document header displaying screening by NARA (RPT) dated July 16, 2026, with FOIA number RD 87542.
I’m trying to figure out the origin of this mystery number

I felt intimidated. Who was this RD 87542? I pictured him or her as some erudite-looking NARA regular with interests similar to my own but with vastly superior FOIA skills. Other questions I had were: how did RD 87542 come to be interested in the missing person records too, which were listed in one lonely line item among hundreds of line items on a spreadsheet posted online by Government Attic? When did they submit their request and how did they manage to obtain all (minus one) of the missing person records so quickly in comparison to my measly 18 records? And was this person a local, able to visit NARA whenever they felt like it, or did they agree to spend the $760 to have copies made, which was the quote NARA had given me in 2022 if I requested all the records?

But mostly, I wondered why NARA was working so hard to complete RD 87542’s FOIA request by August 14 when it was just me, and not the erudite regular, who was coming to town to review them? 

When I got back home, I sent a follow-up email asking about the record that hadn’t been processed and also if I could have a copy of FOIA request number RD 87542. I knew they’d probably redact the person’s identifying information, but I didn’t care. I wanted to learn whatever I could about that request and its requester.

My contact from NARA asked: “Could you elaborate on what you mean when you ask if you can ‘obtain a copy of FOIA request RD87542’?”

I elaborated and was subsequently told that it wasn’t a FOIA request. Here are her exact words:

“RD 87542 was the number assigned to a proactive review project for Entry UD-15D 33 Classification 79 (Missing Persons) Headquarters Case Files. There was no FOIA request for these records.”

On the missing person envelopes, RD 87542 is explicitly written as a FOIA number, but I didn’t quibble. I was too busy becoming more suspicious. By that point, I was beginning to wonder if the FBI had stepped in, making it possible for me to see all those records in record time. I felt as though they wanted to steer me in a direction other than the one in which I’d been headed with regard to the numbers in the upper righthand corners of Ron’s FBI records. (The 10’s…I’m talking about Ron’s 10’s.) As I’ve discussed in prior posts, I think the FBI has been cherry-picking its records to mislead the public about the meaning of those numbers and they wanted me to see the missing person records in their entirety (minus one) so that I would arrive at the intended erroneous conclusion. Whereas I think the numbers are indicative of a high-level person who received one or more copies of a designated record, I believe they want to make it appear as if the numbers are based on some yawn-worthy alphabetized clerical system that no one should care about. Their personal preference is that everyone should just move on.

I thanked my contact and then reached out to NARA’s operational FOIA office—the office that handles FOIA requests that pertain to how NARA conducts its own business versus the archival records it manages for other agencies. I asked for the internal operational records pertaining to NARA’s “proactive review project” for the FBI’s missing person records. 

Specifically, I said, “I’m interested in one or more records that were created when the project was initially assigned by someone in a supervisory role plus any additional related instructions/guidance provided by a supervisor regarding that proactive review project.”

What I really wanted to know was if NARA had initiated this proactive review project because they wanted me to have as many records as possible even after I’d whittled down my request, or did someone else tell them to do it? And if someone told them to do it, who was that person and why were they so interested in my request for missing person records? 

My new request regarding the proactive review project was simple and straightforward. Find the person who sent the email or emails instructing NARA staffers to finish processing all of the missing person files, make copies of those emails, and send them to me. If the instructions had come from in-house, then everyone involved is likely in the same building. Any questions that someone might have about my request could be resolved with a walk down the hall. Also, the timeframe wasn’t that long ago so the emails should still be on everyone’s servers. And I wasn’t asking for every email on the subject. I was asking only for the emails that came from one or more supervisors giving instructions or guidance about this particular proactive review project. How hard could that be?

Incidentally, this was a request that someone in charge should have relished. They were being proactive and it was a nice opportunity for them to brag a little.

On September 16, I received an email from NARA telling me that my request fell under one of their “unusual circumstances” categories, which means that they needed more than the requisite 20 business days to respond. 

Their reason for the additional time was:

“…we need to search for and collect potentially responsive records from an office separate from our office [emphasis added] which is processing the request,” they wrote.

They also said that they would need “an additional 10 working days from the date of this letter.”

After 12 working days had passed and I received no word, I wrote to them seeking a status update.

Here’s the status update I received today:

“Our estimated time to completion is 58 months from today. This is a conservative estimate, and cases may move more quickly through the queue. If you do not receive a response within this estimated completion time, please contact us again for a status update.”

Hilarious, right? The first person guesstimated 10 additional working days, which ended several days ago, but the second person said, whoops, our bad! See you in 4.83 years, sucker!

Apparently, my simple, straightforward FOIA request has made its way to the complex FOIA queue and I’m number 579 in line.

Look, I don’t know what’s going on, but my guess is that it has to do with the office that’s “separate” from NARA’s FOIA office. Gosh, what office could that possibly be?

I have my suspicions.

***********

ADDENDUM: I’m seeking assistance from the Office of Government Information Services, which is also part of the National Archives, to mediate my FOIA request regarding NARA’s proactive review project. They get a lot of requests, but I figured it was worth a shot. Here’s the email that I sent them today:

Email correspondence regarding a FOIA request, including PDFs of original request, acknowledgment, and status updates.
Click on image for a closer view

An epiphany: more evidence that the FBI cherry-picks the records it releases to the public…and other observations!

In my August 27 post, I made a wild claim about the FBI. I had the gall to accuse them of cherry-picking the records they release to the public to try to mislead us. I knew I was putting myself out on a limb by saying it, but I felt confident, so I said it anyway. 

Well…thanks to you, my insightful readers, I’ve had an epiphany on this topic, which provides us with more supporting evidence that the FBI has been misleading the public for a long time with regard to its record releases.

I know that many of you are busy watching football tonight, so I’ll try to keep this brief. Also, while we may be rooting for different teams, I like to think that there’s one individual who unites us all, win or lose, through thick or thin, whether we beat the spread or fall short.

And that is Kirk Herbstreit’s dog, Peter. 🐕 ❤️

OK, let’s get down to it. There’s no other way to do this than a Q&A. 

When you say the FBI has been cherry-picking, are you talking about more than just Ron Tammen’s records?

I am. This is more than Ron’s records. I’m now talking about all, or at least most, of the records the FBI has released to the public—JFK, RFK, MLK, Watergate, etc., etc., etc., and so on, and so forth.

The reason that I think they’re cherry-picking their records is that they don’t want the public to figure out what the numbers in the upper righthand corners mean. 

How are they cherry-picking their records?

They want us to think that the numbers in the upper righthand corner represent some sort of alphabetical grouping based on the subject of the document. According to their made-up system, names beginning with an A are given a 1; some names beginning with B get a 1, while others get a 2. Some Cs get a 2, while others, along with the Ds and Es, get a 3. At the opposite end, some of the S’s, all of the T’s, and all of the U’s get a 10. The V’s are a virtual free-for-all—I’ll be showing you why later. The W’s through Z’s get an 11. It would be an insane system with no discernible purpose, which is why I don’t believe they used it. 

When I say they cherry-picked, I’m saying that they tried to make it appear as if it was an alphabetical system by only releasing the records of subjects from a certain part of the alphabet for each number while holding back the records for subjects representing the rest of the alphabet. They’re making it look like it’s an alphabetical system in order to hide the true meaning behind the numbers.

Why would they care if we found out about the true meaning of the numbers?

My hypothesis is that the numbers refer to important people who received one or more copies of that record. In previous posts, I’ve suggested that they’re the FBI liaisons to various federal agencies, but I’m not married to that idea. They could be other categories of people. The only qualifying factor is that they occupy an important office somewhere—be it inside or outside the FBI—and the FBI felt that they should be kept in the loop. But I don’t think the FBI wants us to know who was privy to their records. It might open up a can of worms or something. 

So while I may not understand the specifics of why they’re doing it, I do have additional evidence that they’re doing it, thanks to my recent epiphany.

You said that your readers helped you arrive at your epiphany. Who exactly are you referring to?

I hope I don’t embarrass anyone, but I’m referring to comments made by two readers. The first comment was made by someone who goes by the username Whereaboutsstillunknown. Shortly after I uploaded my August 27 post—and I’m talking maybe within 15 minutes—this person made an observation that completely upended the way I saw things. Then, a second commenter whose username is a long string of numbers and letters told me about the existence of a document that discusses FBI indexing, which I was able to find online. When I considered Whereabouts’ observation alongside the information in number-guy’s document while reviewing the original FBI missing person records—namely, the ones that are in color—it finally dawned on me who was writing the numbers in the righthand corner. All of the sudden, everything made sense.

Who was writing the numbers in the righthand corner?

Don’t you want to know what Whereabouts said in his or her comment first?

OK. What was Whereabouts’ comment?

It had to do with a scribbled notation I’d found on several missing person records: “o’d on yellow.” I thought the “o” represented an o, as in the letter o, and I thought it might have stood for the word “office” or “official.” That’s just how my brain works—it sees an o, it thinks of the vowel that comes after a, e, and i and precedes u, and that’s pretty much all it thinks of. I knew that the word yellow referred to a Message Relay sheet, which was a routing cover sheet printed on yellow paper that included a list of federal agencies with neighboring boxes to check. The FBI used them when they wanted to send copies of certain records to one or more other federal agencies. In my theory, there was no reason to write anything on those sheets other than its recipients. Also in my theory, “o’d on yellow” meant that they’d written a number in the upper righthand corner of a Message Relay sheet to represent an office or official who’d been cc’d.

As a corroborating example, I’d pointed out a different notation that said “7 circled on yellow.” They were explicitly saying that they’d written the number 7 on a Message Relay sheet and circled it. In my theory, adding a number to the top right corner of a Message Relay sheet confirmed that a person represented by the number 7 received a copy.

In my closer, to get reader input, I asked for other suggestions of what the o might have stood for.

Shortly after I hit the “post” button, Whereabouts asked this amazing question: 

“…since someone had written ‘circled on yellow,’ my initial guess is that those might be drawn circles and not o’s?”

That’s brilliant, thought I. Seriously, seriously brilliant.

“That’s a great guess!”, I stated in an understated way.

Still, I had questions. Notations on other Message Relay sheets, whenever I was lucky enough to find one, didn’t seem to fit the “number circled on yellow” scenario. Namely, I wasn’t seeing any circled numbers on Message Relay sheets. I’d found an “o’d 2” on Lady Bird Johnson’s Message Relay and a few “op2” on other people’s Message Relays. Then I read the detailed document about how the indexing system worked plus a few other helpful documents and the fog lifted.

What did you learn when you put everything together?

I learned how important the Files and Communications Division was in the grand scheme of FBI operations. The Files and Communications Division, which was later renamed the Records Management Division, took in all mail, no matter the source, and routed it to the most appropriate recipient(s) while saving copies in its enormous Central Records filing system. Files and Communications were the eyes, ears, noses, and tastebuds of the FBI—the ones who, after being presented with totally new information, determined who all needed to see it.

Seriously, try to imagine all of the mail that FBI Headquarters receives in a day covering a range of wildly different topics. A college student from Cleveland goes missing from his dorm; several men are caught in the wee hours at DNC headquarters, one of whom used to work for the FBI and CIA; a wiretap is found in Dan Rowan’s Las Vegas hotel room; a U.S. president has been assassinated in Dallas. Who should they forward it to? Who needs to know? 

In addition, Files and Communications staff were the ones who typed the index cards that made up the General Index—the colossal indexing system (at one time totaling 65 million cards!) that was the starting point when an agent wanted to access a particular case file. They were also the people who assigned a classification number and case number to every single FBI case, which also numbered in the millions. Not only were they the eyes, ears, noses, and tastebuds of the FBI, I guess you could say they were the prefrontal cortex too. 

Most significantly to you and me, they were the people who wrote on the FBI records in blue pencil.

Are you saying that they were the ones who wrote the numbers in the upper righthand corner?

Indeed, I am. I’m also saying that they likely wrote the other phrases that were typically found in blue on an original FBI record, including “see index,” “FD-217,” and “o’d on yellow.”

What was with those ridiculous little circles?

Please don’t disparage the little circles. Those little circles had purpose. They were what helped me figure everything out. 

One of the first things a Files and Communications employee would do when they were handed a piece of mail was to locate the name or names that would require an index card. Sometimes the index card had already been made, such as for longstanding ruffians Carlos Marcello and Santo Trafficante. Other times they’d need to create a new one. It didn’t matter. On every incoming piece of mail, the Files and Communications folks would always, always, always draw a circle in front of the person’s last name (if we’re talking about a person) or another important reference word. And those circles were always, always, always written in blue.

You know what else was always written in blue? The classification and case numbers. 

What about the notes written in blue? How and why would the Files and Communications Division write those notes?

Keep in mind that the Files and Communications Division was massive. One unit was doing the indexing, another unit doing the classifying, another assigning case numbers, another assigning the serial numbers at the end of case numbers, and so on. (I’m not saying that the jobs were exhilarating. I’m just saying that there was a lot to be done.) You also had a unit doing routing. Separate from all of that, another unit was conducting background checks for other federal agencies. Plus you had unit supervisors, section supervisors and, ultimately, a division head.

Here’s a nice flow chart to help you picture the operation. (As far as I can tell, it was called the Records Branch before it was Files and Communications.)

Flow chart illustrating the processes of the Records Branch, including steps for routing, name searching, classification, indexing, numbering, and recording.
Click on image for a closer view

If, as I believe, the Files and Communications Division was writing the additional notes in blue, that would explain:

  • The numbers in the righthand corner  – someone high up in routing might add one or more numbers from 1 through 11 to indicate the important people or office who should receive a copy of the record. Sometimes they’d follow the number with a hyphen and the number 1 or 2 to indicate how many copies they should receive.
  • See index – Someone high up would write this on some records to notify the agent assigned to the case that the subject was on the Security Index. 
  • FD-217 – When a field office didn’t know the case number, they’d include this form with their report, which, I believe, also provided information about what number to put in the upper righthand corner. Someone high up in routing would sometimes reference the FD-217 form when they added the number in the upper right.
  • o’d on yellow – This one is a little trickier.

How is “o’d on yellow” trickier? And what about the unresolved issue you had with the phrase “o’d on yellow” when there weren’t any numbers circled on Message Relay sheets?

Wow. You really do love frolicking in the weeds, don’t you? OK, so my unresolved issue had to do with the Message Relay sheets that said “o’d 2” or “op2” but that didn’t have any numbers circled. As it turns out, those notations weren’t referring to the numbers in the upper righthand corner. They were in reference to the circle placed in front of a last name, which happened to be on page 2 of the record that was being relayed.

Remember Lady Bird Johnson’s o’d 2 from my blog post? On page 2 of that transmission, they’d placed a circle in front of the name Johnson, probably in blue, but, unfortunately, I don’t have the original so I can’t confirm that. Likewise, the op2 people also had circles in front of their last names on page 2, also probably in blue. (The p stands for page.)

A teletype message relay form dated April 2, 1981, sent from the FBI. The document is classified as 'UNCLASS' and lists several government agencies and officials as recipients. It includes sections for approval, originator details, and a note about communication services available to government agencies.
Click on image for a closer view
A document marked 'UNCLOSED' from the FBI dated September 28, 1981, discussing the visit of Mrs. Lyndon B. Johnson to Washington, D.C. from September 26 to September 30, 1981. The document emphasizes that it is unclassified and should not be filed without a communication stamp.
Click on image for a closer view

Here’s the op2 for Sam Giancana:

A message relay document from the FBI dated 4/8/75, featuring various checkboxes for communication with different government agencies, with handwritten notes and a classified section.
Click on image for a closer view
A handwritten document dated April 17, 1973, discussing legal matters, including a strike and travel plans related to businesses in Chicago. The document contains names and procedural notes, with sections obscured or crossed out for confidentiality.
Click on image for a closer view

As for the “o’d on yellow” folks, the Files and Communications Division would sometimes write the subject’s name on the Message Relay sheet and add the circle in front of the person’s last name. That’s what I believe they’d done in several designated missing person files. (Unfortunately, they neglected to include the Message Relay sheets in their files so I can’t confirm.) Nevertheless, here’s an example of our old friend James McCord’s Message Relay with the circle in front of his last name:

A classified teletype message relay from the FBI Director dated June 11, 1973, addressed to various high-ranking officials including the President, Vice President, and members of the military and intelligence sectors, with a note on unclassified information.
Click on image for a closer view

The take-home here is that “o’d on yellow” referred to the circles in front of last names corresponding to the alphabetized index cards in the General Index. Those were different from the “7 circled on yellow” example, which I believe was referring to a 7 that had been written in the righthand corner of a Message Relay sheet. In both examples, the notation for circle was the same, but the reason for the circles differed. 

OK, enough shop talk. Let’s talk about the most important reason for this blog post.

What about the additional evidence you have that the numbers refer to actual people and that the FBI has been cherry-picking the records it releases to the public?

First and foremost, if the Files and Communications Division was responsible for the numbers in the upper righthand corner, there’s no way that those numbers had anything to do with some internal, arbitrarily subdivided alphabetical system that would benefit no one. Those staff members were working too hard at maintaining the General Index system, which was 100 percent alphabetical, as well as the case filing system, which was purely numerical. An FBI staffer would look up a name in the General Index, which supplied them with one or more case numbers in the Central Records System, prefaced by its classification group, which was also numerical. It was a perfectly logical system and the Files and Communications Division was married to it. There was no reason for them to add arbitrarily subdivided categories within a classification group to the betterment of no one.

OK, so hear me out. What if there was some internal operational reason for the numbers? For example, what if they were written to help the people who were responsible for filing the records in the Central Records System? You’ve said yourself that it was a huge filing system. What if those numbers referred to room numbers to help them know where to go?

That’s sweet. But there’s no way they would do that. Files and Communications staff would draw the circles, they’d write the classification and case numbers, and they’d write the special notes, all of which were helpful to the agents reading the records. And let’s focus solely on the Message Relay sheets. The recipients represented the White House, the CIA, the Attorney General’s office, and the like. There’s no way that someone from the Files and Communications staff would write helpful little notes to their colleagues who filed the records, and, what’s more, to do so only on occasion, if they were feeling big-hearted. It was the filers’ job to know where to go. 

Do you have other evidence that the numbers refer to actual people and that the FBI has been cherry-picking the records it releases to the public?

Absolutely. Just for fun, I created an Excel sheet of all of the missing person records I recently obtained from the National Archives. Next to each person’s name, I placed the number or numbers that were in the upper righthand corners in their own box or cell. Then I added other well-known subjects to the list—such as Carlos Marcello and Santo Trafficante—with their respective numbered boxes to find out if anyone fell outside of the made-up, arbitrarily subdivided system. 

Granted, there weren’t a ton of people who fell outside. I imagine someone’s job was (and maybe still is?) to pull only the records that match the arbitrarily subdivided system, and they’ve gotten good at it. Thankfully, nobody’s perfect and everyone can have an off day now and again. Listed below is a sampling of the more well-known people and organizations who have one or more records that fall outside of the FBI’s made-up system. 

For your assistance, I included a circle in front of the names that had been indexed. Also, note that I believe the numbers after the hyphens are the numbers of copies that the designated official received. A 3-1 versus a 3-2 tells me that official 3 received 1 copy in the first example and two copies in the second. If only the number is listed or a number plus a hyphen, I believe they received 1 copy.

Bella oAbzug

Should have had a 1, but was assigned a 3-1 instead.

A confidential memorandum from the United States Government to the FBI regarding an individual named Bella S. Abzug, dated February 19, 1965. The document discusses the subject's residence and employment status, and mentions that no significant information was obtained about their activities.
Click on image for a closer view

Spiro oAgnew

Should have had a 1, but received a 10 instead after a possible assassination attempt.

FBI communication dated October 1, 1973, detailing a possible assassination attempt on Vice President Spiro T. Agnew in Rancho Mirage, California. The report mentions a shot fired near the Frank Sinatra compound, where Secret Service agents were present. No evidence was found.
Click on image for a closer view

Princess oDiana and Prince oCharles

Although the 2-2 and 3-2 would fit the made-up system for Charles’ and Diana’s names, their Message Relay sheet, which preceded a report for a potential bomb plot, had an added 10-2 as well.

A teletype message relay form labeled 'MESSAGE RELAY VIA TELETYPE', dated July 31, 1981, containing multiple checkboxes for various government departments and agencies including the President, Department of Treasury, and Federal Aviation Administration. The form includes sections for additional remarks and approval signatures.
Click on image for a closer view

oCentral Intelligence Agency’s Intentions to Send Hoodlums to Cuba to Assassinate Castro

Should have had a 2 but was given an 8- instead.

Top secret document dated March 6, 1967, from the FBI discussing the CIA's intentions to send operatives to Cuba to assassinate Fidel Castro, containing confidential information and investigative details.
Click on image for a closer view

Judith oCoplon, Soviet spy and DOJ employee

Should have had a 3, but got a 7-1 instead.

Confidential memo dated December 31, 1948, from the Washington Field Office to the FBI Director, discussing espionage activities involving individuals from July 20, 1944, to January 8, 1945. The document references Judith Coplon and her employment history with the U.S. government, highlighting her involvement in espionage and analysis related to foreign agents.
Click on image for a closer view

John oDenver

Was given a 10-2 and 11-2 in addition to his 3-2 for threats against his life

Teletype message relay from FBI Director dated January 2, 1980, addressed to various government agencies including the President, CIA, and Department of Energy. The document is marked as unclassified and includes instructions for attachments and contact information.
Click on image for a closer view

Meyer oLansky

Should have had 6’s, but received a 9 on two records and a 10-, and 11 on one.

FBI teletyped communication dated March 22, 1973, regarding urgent matters relating to Meyer Lansky, including notes about obtaining affidavits.
Click on image for a closer view

Carlos oMarcello

Should have received 7’s but received 8’s on two records.

FBI teletype document dated August 4, 1964, regarding preliminary interviews related to Carlos Marcello's trial for fraud, mentioning jurors advocating for his acquittal.
Click on image for a closer view; because this page is an original, you can see that the 8 is written in blue pencil

Santo oTrafficante

Should have received a 10 but got a 9 instead.

A decoded diplomatic cable document detailing a telephone call about an individual's travel to Madrid and Portugal, mentioning contact with a Cuban attorney and referencing internal security matters related to Cuba.
Click on image for a closer view

Werner oVon Braun

Should have received an 11, but received on several records: 2-1; 3-1; 4; 7 and 7-1; 8; 9, 9-, and 9-1’s; and, OK, a couple 11s and an 11-1. (This is what I mean when I say that the only V example I have is a free-for-all.) Here are a few examples:

An official FBI document dated March 5, 1963, containing redacted information and instructions for transmitting information via regular mail. The document lists enclosures, including letters and articles, related to espionage and communications to the Pittsburgh office.
Click on image for a closer view
A blacked-out U.S. government memorandum addressed to the FBI director, dated August 20, 1958, with the subject of espionage.
Click on image for a closer view
A partially redacted teletyped communication from the FBI dated May 15, 1961, discussing an individual named Wernher Magnus Maximilian von Braun, including instructions for investigation and employment details.
Click on image for a closer view
Confidential memorandum from the FBI, dated April 25, 1960, regarding visitors to Poland, with significant portions redacted.
Click on image for a closer view

Illinois Governor Dan oWalker

Should have received an 11, but got a 2 instead.

A memorandum from the United States Government addressed to the Acting Director of the FBI, dated February 26, 1973, discussing a meeting with Illinois Governor Daniel Walker regarding civil unrest and communications protocols.
Click on image for a closer view

I also need to tell you about one interesting missing person document.

What’s that?

This was a tragic case involving a 13-year-old African-American girl named Dorothy Sampson. Dorothy had gone missing in Fayette, Mississippi, on December 8, 1970, after running an errand for her neighbor. She was subsequently found in an oil field on Christmas day of that same year, sexually assaulted and murdered. The story is too grim to include here, however the reason I bring it up is that civil rights leader Charles Evers, the mayor of Fayette and older brother to famed civil rights leader Medgar Evers (who was assassinated on June 12, 1963), had been implicated by informants as having been involved in the murder. Although Charles was no angel, I don’t believe it for one minute. He was never charged. The racism in this case was off the charts, and Dorothy’s file makes me sick to my stomach.

What I want to share with you is a record dated 9/13/72. You can see the circle in front of the name oSampson. You can also see a circle in front of a name that has been redacted, which I believe to be Evers. There are two blue numbers in the upper righthand corner—a 6 and a 9. Because Dorothy’s last name is at the front end of the S’s, her 9 is consistent with the FBI’s made-up system, even though later S’s received 10’s. (See what I mean about their arbitrary subdivisions?) But Charles Evers should have gotten a 3, not a 6. Now look more closely at those numbers in the righthand corner. Can you see where the numbers 3-1, 10-1, 11-1, and 5-1 were once there, but were subsequently erased? The 10, 11, and 5 don’t fit the FBI’s made-up system. Other writing was erased too.

FBI air mail document dated September 13, 1972, regarding the alleged murder of Dorothy Mary Sampson in Fayette, Mississippi. Includes information about investigation leads and communication with local authorities.
Click on image for a closer view; note that, because these are originals, the numbers are written in blue pencil

Now look at the bottom of the page, under LEADS, written in regular pencil. It reads (to the best that I can tell): “No dissemination to White House as no pertinent info developed on Evers.”

Did someone overrule several of the numbers in the righthand corner and is that why some of them were erased? Does that notation confirm that the numbers are in reference to the FBI’s secret dissemination list? Could one of the erased numbers be in reference to the White House? I could be wrong due to the placement of the note on the record and the fact that a similar note had been written on several other records, but I thought I should let you know.

OK, I think I’ve said enough today. Have a great weekend, and, as always, if you spot anything I’ve missed, please feel free to weigh in!

As requested: three more samples of Ron Tammen’s handwriting…

I know what you’re thinking. You’re thinking that, after I learned that the notation “366 m hau” wasn’t in reference to Robert Maheu that I’d probably given up on a Robert Maheu connection to Ron Tammen altogether. But that’s not the case.

I have absolutely, 100%, not given up on a Maheu connection. The reason is that I continue to believe that Ron’s “Hac” notations could be in reference to Howard Hughes. HAC was a commonly used acronym for the Hughes Aircraft Company, which, according to Larry DuBois and Laurence Gonzales in their explosive 1976 Playboy article, had a cozy relationship with the CIA. My theory is that Hac was FBI shorthand for Howard Hughes. Supporting evidence is that Hac is also found on at least two of Hank Greenspun’s FBI records as well as one record for the New England chapter of the Committee for Non-Violent Action (CNVA). Hank Greenspun was friends with Howard Hughes as well as Robert Maheu, Howard’s long-time public-facing representative after Hughes began living life as a recluse. The CNVA was opposed to underground nuclear testing, an issue that Hughes also felt passionate about, especially if the testing was conducted near Las Vegas. I think it’s entirely feasible that Hughes supported them financially.

If I’m correct that Hac stands for Howard Hughes, then Robert Maheu knew Ron Tammen.

And so…remember when I discussed the possibility that a man with phone-tampering skills who went by the alias J.W. Harrison and who worked for Robert Maheu just might have been our Ron? I haven’t given up on that possibility either. In that post, I showed a handwriting sample of Harrison’s and suggested that, at some point, we might want to hire a forensic document examiner to compare his writing to Ron’s signature. I then wondered if it would be possible to obtain at least two other writing samples of Ron’s that were lengthier than just his signature.

Well, guess what, Good Man readers. Our dear friend Grace, Ron Tammen’s date to his senior prom, has kindly provided those samples to us. Better yet, she provided, not two, but three samples.

Here they are:

From the 1950 Maple Leaf yearbook; Ron was a junior and Grace was a freshman.
From the 1951 Maple Leaf yearbook. Ron was a senior and Grace was a sophomore.
Also from the 1951 Maple Leaf, where Ron also signed his picture: “My best wishes always, Grace. Ronald Tammen”

Are those great, or what?

Now, for your comparison, here’s the hotel registration written by J.W. Harrison in October 1960, nine years after Ron Tammen signed Grace’s sophomore yearbook.

Click on image for a closer view

Look, I’m no expert, and I definitely see differences. But nine years is a long time, and our handwriting does change over the years. I used to be so careful with my own handwriting, and now I can’t read it.

For me, I can see two similarities: the balloon-like initial J compared to Ron’s R, and the curlicue in the front of the F in San Francisco.

Ron made curlicues too. You can see a big one at the front of “My” over Ron’s picture above. You can see other attempted curlicues in the front of the T in Tammen in the signatures below, which were written in other people’s 1950 and 1951 yearbooks.

Click on image for a closer view
Click on image for a closer view

In my post on J.W. Harrison, I said that it probably wasn’t Ron, but it’s still a question worth asking. Right now, I need to save my pennies, but when the time is right, I’ll definitely be hiring a specialist to give us the final word.

In the meantime, happy Labor Day and thank you to all of America’s workers.

***********

Addendum: Just for fun, I’ve made a comparison of some of the similarities between Ron Tammen’s and J.W. Harrison’s handwriting. Obviously, there are differences. For example, Harrison sometimes switched from conventional cursive letters to a printing style (see his r’s in Harrison and the S in St.). As I’ve mentioned, I will be hiring an expert to review everything at a later date.

I’ve just learned that the FBI is actively trying to throw my Tammen research off track. Here’s what they’ve been up to and how I know

I need to tell you about my recent visit to the National Archives (aka NARA), the one in College Park, Maryland. The reason for my visit was to review old missing person files that the FBI had transferred to them in 2014 and that I’d found out about thanks to the good folks at The Government Attic. I’d requested the records through a FOIA request I submitted in June 2022. In November 2022, someone from NARA wrote the following to me:

“The estimated total page count for your request is approximately 950 pages. Requests between 701 and 3,000 pages are assigned to our second-tier processing queue. To give you an indication of our existing second-tier backlog, we are currently processing requests received in February 2014.

Once we notify you that processing is complete, you may either visit our College Park, MD facility to view the file at no cost, or order a reproduction. Our current fee for reproductions is 80 cents per page, so we estimate the total cost will be $760.00.”

Waiting out an 8-year backlog for the pleasure of forking over $760 seemed a little much to me. Also, College Park is about 350 miles away, so it’s not exactly a day trip. 

The other possibility they suggested was to narrow my request, which I did. I asked to see 18 of the files that I chose somewhat randomly from their list of 87 names I’d never heard of. Two years later, in August 2024, they informed me that my files were ready. Just about two years after that, in June 2026, I told them I was planning a visit to College Park in August. I asked them if I could see the 18 files I’d originally requested and then, on a whim, I said that if they happened to process any more of the 87 files on the list, I’d like to see those too.

I was in luck, they responded. They’d processed more of the files. Great, said I. See you in August.

And see them, I did. When I showed up to NARA’s Textual Records reading room, an archivist handed me a box that held two CDs. The CDs contained 86 of the 87 files of the FBI’s missing person cases from the 1940s, 50s, 60s, and 70s. For the amazingly low price of $5.00, another NARA archivist handed me a thumb drive upon which I could transfer copies of all those cases, which I did. 

I suppose for one fleeting moment I wondered why they’d made me drive all the way to College Park to view records that had been digitized and could have been mailed to me on CDs that would’ve cost far less than $760, but I didn’t really care. I was there now, and what I was looking at on the computer screen made everything worth it. I was now able to compare Ron’s missing person records with a larger sample of people who were also missing during roughly the same period. I could get a sense of which markings were typical, run-of-the-mill missing person markings and which were truly special. I could finally see if Ron’s 10’s and Hacs and underlined lf’s and 366 m hau’s and all the other scribbles I’ve written about over the years held any meaning whatsoever.

Today’s post will be in show-and-tell format. I’ll be sharing several things I learned about Ron’s case after my trip and offering examples from the missing person files that led me to those conclusions. 

Also, as I mentioned in the headline, I’ll be providing evidence that the FBI is attempting to mislead us about the meaning of a certain set of marks in the upper righthand corners of people’s FBI records, including Ron’s. (Spoiler alert: I’m talking about the 10’s…they’re attempting to mislead us about the meaning of Ron’s 10’s.) They’re doing this through a common deceptive practice known as cherry-picking and, I kid you not, I believe that I have the FBI to thank for ensuring that I received almost the entire batch of available missing person records (sans one) so that I’d arrive at the conclusion they wanted me to arrive at. Happily, I’m onto them big time and I have hard evidence that shows everyone what they’ve been up to. So hang on to your Stetsons, cowboys and cowgirls, as we catch the FBI red-handed in some rip-snortin’ cherry-pickin’ trickery. You’ll see what I mean soon. 

Let’s go!

Discovery #1: I don’t think that 366 m hau is in reference to Robert Maheu after all. 

This discovery has taken me well over a week to come to terms with. I’d been so sure that we had this mini-mystery all figured out…that 366 m hau was the same person as LV 366-PC and that person was Robert Maheu, right-hand man to Howard Hughes. But there, staring at me from a September 13, 1972, missing person report was the phrase “366 m hau.” The report concerned a missing woman from Culpeper, VA. It had nothing to do with Las Vegas. I doubt that she knew Howard Hughes, Ash Resnick, or Ronald Tammen either. Therefore, I don’t believe it pertains to an informant broadly or to Robert Maheu specifically, which sucks bigly.

But it does provide some information. Below the 366 m hau, in the same handwriting, are the words “Crim & Dead.” Above it, also in the same handwriting is…I can’t tell. It looks like a 9 with a t and something else, probably someone’s initials. Also, it’s written in regular, graphite-colored pencil, which I believe indicates that it was written by someone in the Identification Division. (That’s versus the blue, red, and green pencil markings I’ve seen on other original FBI records.) As for what “Crim and Dead” stands for, it means “Criminal and Dead,” because I saw that exact phrase written on another person’s missing person record. As I was trying to figure out what that phrase could mean, I discovered that, from roughly 1971 to 1994, there was a Deceased Criminal Identification Files list, which was housed in the Identification Division. The people who were on the list were ostensibly known criminals who were now deceased. Maybe they were referring to that list. Or maybe 366 m hau had checked two lists: the criminals and the dead criminals. The missing woman was deemed a fugitive in three states, so that would warrant the “criminal” description. I don’t know when she died. Also, the Deceased Criminal Identification Files list is available on Ancestry.com, and she isn’t on it. I’m not printing her name because her two daughters appear to be living.

So, bummer-and-a-drag, 366 m hau wasn’t Robert Maheu. But as I mentioned in a recent Facebook post, it doesn’t mean that Robert Maheu didn’t know Ron Tammen. We still have the Hac scribbles on Ron’s pages, which match Robert Maheu’s good friend Hank Greenspun’s Hacs and which did not appear on the 86 missing person files I reviewed. It’s still my theory that Hac refers to the Hughes Aircraft Company, which was a front for the CIA, and might have served as a cover for Ron. The letters Hac could have been FBI shorthand for Howard Hughes, which absolutely would still involve his alter-ego Robert Maheu. We just don’t have a direct reference to Maheu on Ron’s records. It’s OK. It was a fun theory, but I’ve moved on.

Discovery #2: The FBI continued sending form letters with check boxes to families of missing persons after J. Edgar Hoover died. For some reason, they stopped sending them to the Tammens. 

Every few years after Ron disappeared, the FBI would send a form letter to Mr. and Mrs. Tammen asking if Ron was still missing (check this box) or if he’d been located or his location was no longer desired (check this box instead). The Tammens would dutifully check that he was still missing and send the form back. Mr. Tammen continued doing so after Mrs. Tammen died in 1964. But you know what? The last form letter received by Mr. Tammen was in October 1970. In 1972, at roughly the time when the Tammens were due to receive another letter, J. Edgar Hoover died and the form letters stopped arriving. 

I’d wondered if that was just a Hoover practice, and once Hoover had died, the practice was discontinued. But I now know that, even after Hoover died, Acting Director L. Patrick Gray continued sending the same families their form letters, and then Director Clarence Kelley picked up the baton after that. Nevertheless, Mr. Tammen had stopped receiving his form letters about Ron. If I could pinpoint the date that the FBI’s Identification Division stopped caring about Ron’s case, I’d guess it was June 5, 1973, when Ron’s missing person records were “removed from Ident files.” This was shortly after the Cincinnati Field Office had fingerprinted the guy from Welco Industries and sent those fingerprints to Headquarters to run a comparison to Ron’s prints. Something that the FBI had discovered about Ron’s case as they were tracking things down led them to remove Mr. Tammen from the rotation. 

Hmmm…what could it be? I wonder.

Sir Edward Massengill

J. Edgar Hoover checks on the whereabouts of missing person Sir Edward Massengill.
L. Patrick Gray checks on Massengill’s whereabouts after Hoover has died.

David M. Smart

David Smart went missing in August 1971, which preceded Hoover’s death. Although there isn’t a form letter from Hoover in Smart’s file, we see that L. Patrick Gray sent one to the FBI’s field office in Birmingham in 1973.
Clarence Kelley continued checking in on Smart’s whereabouts in 1976.

Discovery #3: A bunch of missing people had ‘see index’ written on their FBI records; likewise, many files were stored in the Missing Person File Room.

I’ve been learning that the people who went missing weren’t perfect angels. They had stories. Some had committed crimes. Many of them probably had good reasons for running away. So I guess it wasn’t too surprising to find that a lot of them had their files stored in the Missing Person File Room, room #1126 of the Identification Building, just like Ron did. I mean, if the FBI sees fit to set aside a special room for the NSFW missing person files, which is my guess regarding its purpose, there are going to be occupants. Still, not all of the missing people had their files stored there. Something was keeping these files apart from the others. 

As for the people with the phrase “see index” scribbled on one or more of their records, if I’m right that it refers to the Security Index, then the FBI did add missing people to the Security Index even if they didn’t know their whereabouts. So I was wrong about that. Also, you might think that if you’re going to have “see index” written on your records, your file is probably going to wind up in the Missing Person File Room, but that’s not the case. There were “see index” people who weren’t in the Missing Person File Room and there were people in the Missing Person File Room who didn’t have “see index” written anywhere. Ron had both. Whether they knew Ron’s whereabouts when they wrote down that phrase on page one of his records, I can’t say. But by June 5, 1973, I think they had a pretty good idea.

Discovery #4: The 10’s on Ron’s records continue to be significant. Maybe they’re even more significant than I realized.

I have a story to share. There I was, reading through the missing person files and organizing them on a spreadsheet of sorts by last name. Next to each person’s last name, I’d type in a few notes, such as whether the person’s file was in the Missing Person File Room, whether the phrase “see index” was written somewhere, plus a few others, including what the number was in the upper righthand corner of their record.

It wasn’t long before I noticed a pattern emerging regarding those numbers. The people who had last names beginning with an A or B had a 1 in their righthand corner; people who had a last name beginning with a C or D had a 2 in their corner; and so on all the way to the S’s and T’s, which had 10’s. The three people whose names started with a W had an 11. There were outliers, but the pattern was undeniable.

What…the bloody…hell, thought I, as my entire world began to implode. I think I became light-headed. Ron’s 10’s are central to my theory that he was living a life of danger for the CIA. The other cases in which I found 10’s described some remarkable circumstances as well.

But if Ron’s 10’s are there simply because his last name starts with a T, then I’m officially done here. Game over. I’ll take down my blog site, remove myself from society, and live my life in solemn quietude. Maybe I’ll get another cat…or 10. I can think of several people out there who’d be overjoyed with this development. In all seriousness, this may have been the closest I’ve come to a full-on existential crisis.

As many of you know, my theory has been that those numbers refer to an official within the FBI who received a copy of the record. Sometimes the numbers are followed by a dash followed by a 1 or 2 or sometimes an even higher number, indicating how many copies they received. I also posited that the official was the FBI’s liaison to a federal agency and that Ron’s 10’s were in reference to the FBI’s liaison to the Secret Service. To be honest, I wasn’t as sure about what agencies they represented—maybe they represented outside agencies or maybe they represented certain offices within the Department of Justice, which oversees the FBI—but I was certain that the number in the righthand corner represented a person. And now this.

But…but…but…(thought I)…it didn’t make any sense for them to alphabetize names within a classification group. It doesn’t follow FBI protocol. FBI protocol at that time was simple and straightforward. First, they checked the general index, which consisted of thousands, and probably hundreds of thousands, of index cards organized alphabetically by people’s names and other identifiers, all meticulously cross-referenced. The index card would then provide the appropriate case number (or numbers) for that person, with the first part of the case number being the classification group, which for missing persons is the number 79. The FBI staffer would then stroll over to where the case files were housed, find the 79 classification group, and pull out the respective file. Ron’s number was 79-31966. Richard Cox’s number was 79-23729. Ronnie York’s was 79-32021. Anna Marie Altmeier’s was 79-31499. And so on. (Oh, I know, I know. What about the Missing Person File Room? I’m thinking that the index card likely mentioned if the file was in there instead, where they’d also be filed by their case numbers. No biggie.) Nowhere have I read that the FBI grouped files alphabetically within a classification group. And think about it: A case file is much easier to locate by its case number than by having to also know some sort of alphabetized section number assigned to it and written in the upper righthand corners of some, but not all, of that person’s records. And what if there were two or more numbers, which sometimes occurred? Does that mean that copies were made so that the files would be in multiple places within the classification group? That would be insane.

So what’s a girl do when she’s presented with this kind of life-altering, book-project-killing information? I’ll tell you what she does. She pours herself a glass of passion fruit kombucha and continues reading the missing person records while taking notes.

Here’s what she found.

The dashes, 1’s, and 2’s

Many of the numbers had dashes followed by 1’s and 2’s too. Why would they have those additional numbers if they were organized alphabetically within the classification group, which, again, would be insane?

Here are examples from 1 to 11:

Here are two examples of outliers in which multiple numbers are listed. In the Sampson example, according to my theory, FBI reps #3 and #9 received 1 copy of the record, and reps #1 and #9 received two copies of the enclosures.

The FD-217’s

Several of the missing person records have the notation “FD-217” scribbled near their number. As you may recall, many of the non-missing-person records also have the FD-217 notation near their number, as if that notation was the reason for that particular number being assigned. 

To recap from a while ago, the FD-217 was an FBI form titled “Notification of Bureau File Number,” which, to the best of my knowledge, was generally submitted by field offices along with a report if they didn’t know the person’s case number. I think it provides more interesting information than that though, since I can’t get my hands on one, not even one that’s blank. The FBI claims that they can’t find it, even though I pointed them to a page number in the FBI Form Book’s Table of Contents.

Someone’s initials are usually written near the number and FD-217 notation, as if they’re saying “I checked the FD-217 and it provided this number.” If the numbers were merely some sort of alphabetical shorthand (e.g., 1= A-B, 2=C-D, etc.), they wouldn’t need to check the FD-217. They could just hang an alphabet chart on a wall somewhere.

The blue pencil

Unlike other missing person records I’ve seen over the years, including Ron’s, these missing person records are originals, which is especially helpful, because I can see what colors the notations are written in. Consistently, the number in the upper righthand corner is written in blue pencil, just like the phrase “see index,” FD-217 (usually, except for the one on pink above), and the accompanying initials. For some time, I’ve believed the blue pencil indicates that it was written by someone in Domestic Intelligence, Division 5, because of the notations, with “see index” being the biggest giveaway. I continue to feel that way.

The yellow sheet

If I were a practitioner of inverted-pyramid journalism versus my usual preference of romping through the weeds on my way to completing a full circle or, if the situation calls for it, a 3-D rhombus, I would’ve led with this next finding. It’s a big deal.

Sometimes, I noticed the phrase “o’d on yellow” or “o’ed on yellow,” also in blue pencil, in the top right of a page that had no number. It was as if the phrase was written in lieu of the number. I had no idea what the phrase meant, but I typed it into my quasi spreadsheet anyway.

Here are 6 examples. The writing is sometimes small and light, but it’s always in blue in the upper right.

Then I read the missing person records associated with Edward Theodore Myers, who, in 1954, at the age of 50, had been missing for about 10 years when his mother wrote to the FBI. At the top of the page on which her letter was affixed, on both sides, someone wrote “7 circled on yellow.” 

“What’s with all the yellow?” I wondered.

I soon learned that the word yellow was referring to the preprinted “Message Relay” cover sheet, which is yellow in color. When the FBI passed along information about a missing person case to a senator, the attorney general, or another important person or agency all the way up to the White House, they’d use the Message Relay cover sheet. It had two purposes: to specify the officials on the distribution list and to hide from casual view the contents of the document being transferred. The fact that someone wrote the number 7 on a Message Relay cover sheet for Edward Theodore Myers tells us that whoever 7 is, they were on the distribution list and they should get a copy too.

As for what the “o” in “o’d” or “o’ed” stands for, I wish I could tell you. Maybe it stands for “office” or maybe “official.” As bizarre as it sounds, maybe it was FBI lingo to write that they’d “o’d on yellow” if they’d written the office’s or official’s designated number on the Message Relay sheet. As further confirmation that the numbers in the top right corner correspond to the numbers written on a Message Relay sheet, I found a Message Relay sheet for Lady Bird Johnson in which the phrase “o’d 2” is written in the top right.

It appears that an agency official with the 2 designation had been kept in the loop about Lady Bird Johnson, whose name, I feel the need to point out, doesn’t start with a C or a D. I also have located non-missing-person examples in which the number on a Message Relay sheet matches the numbers assigned to the regular FBI records. In short, the numbers in the upper righthand corner correspond with the numbers on Message Relay sheets, and none of them have anything to do with where a person’s name falls in the alphabet.

Incidentally, this is also evidence that the FBI didn’t save all of its missing person records. Even though they wrote “o’d on yellow” on someone’s records, they didn’t bother to save a copy of the Message Relay sheets for the missing person files. “TMI,” they likely thought.

The file envelopes

For additional corroboration, let’s talk again about FBI protocol. When an FBI staffer pulled someone’s file, the individual records were stored in a manila envelope. Stamped on the envelope on the righthand side was the case file number, because, as we’ve discussed, that’s how the files were organized. Nowhere on the outer envelope is a number ranging from 1 to 11 that corresponds to the numbers written in blue pencil in the top righthand corner of some of the pages of a person’s records—numbers that the FBI would have us believe represents some sort of secondary alphabetized system. Those numbers aren’t on the envelopes because, again, that would be insane.

To conclude this section, the above examples confirm that the numbers in the upper righthand corner hold meaning, Ron’s 10’s continue to be significant, and I don’t need to go dig a hole in which to live out my days.

I’d mentioned earlier that I found some 10’s in the missing person records as well. As with Ron’s 10’s, not all are clear as to why they earned them, but here are several that do seem a little more self-explanatory and far juicier than the other, lower-numbered records:

David Smart, aerospace engineer for NASA who disappeared on his way to work

Roger Alan Smith, a Marine who’d just completed training in counterintelligence and was being sought by Naval Intelligence

Andrew J. Tyler, a college student in the Air Force ROTC who had participated in marches against the Vietnam War

Discovery #5: I now believe that the FBI is actively attempting to mislead us 

Here’s the question that’s on most of our minds: Why does it appear as if the numbers from 1 to 11 on the missing person records are based on the alphabet? Answer: the FBI cherry-picked the records. When the FBI released the missing person records to NARA in 2014, I strongly believe that they chose records to make it appear as if the numbers were alphabetically based. To represent the 1’s, they chose people with 1’s on their records whose last names started with A’s and B’s—and only those people. For the 2’s, they chose people with 2’s on their records whose last names started with C’s and D’s, and so on. As a result, I think there are a lot more missing person files out there from that era. 

In an April 14, 1952, article in Life about Richard Cox’s disappearance, authors Herbert Brean and Luther Conant estimated that roughly a million Americans “excluding criminals” attempted to disappear each year. They also said that 95 percent of those cases were solved by missing person departments. Still, that leaves roughly 50,000 people per year who managed to stay hidden. In comparison, the FBI transferred 87 files representing the years 1947 to 1980. Eighty-seven.

I don’t think the FBI was cherry-picking their files because of me. Those files were transferred to NARA long before I started my blog and got all vocal about the numbers in the upper righthand corner. It could be that that’s how the FBI, as a rule, releases its records, in case anyone should question those numbers and as a time-saver to reduce the number of redactions they’d have to make. 

I do, however, think that I was on the FBI’s and NARA’s minds in June 2026, when I let them know that I’d be coming to town. After they finished my request in August 2024, NARA continued working on the rest of those files for a year, processing 48 more. Then they took a 9-month break. Maybe they thought I didn’t care about the files anymore. Maybe they thought I’d moved onto other things so they felt they could expend their time and resources elsewhere. But then, when I told them in June that I’d be coming to College Park in August, they flew into high gear. They processed 20 more files, totaling 86.

Look, I’m extremely grateful to NARA for making all of those files available to me so quickly. They accomplished that feat in only four years when I’d been forewarned that they were still working under an 8-year backlog. But I don’t think that the FBI has ever forgiven me for asking for NARA’s assistance in determining why the FBI was able to expunge Ron’s fingerprints 30 years earlier than their normal record retention period would permit. I think it’s highly likely that someone at the FBI read NARA the riot act for giving me information that led to my conclusion that it was due to a conflict with the Privacy Act, and, if so, Ron was probably alive in 2002 and the FBI knew it. I’m thinking there’s probably a note in red somewhere on my NARA researcher profile telling them to contact the FBI whenever I ask for anything that pertains to the Bureau. I think they probably told the FBI that I was coming and I think the FBI told them to finish the files (sans one). If anyone from the FBI has been reading my blog, they knew that I’d be looking at those numbers. I think the FBI wanted me to see its handiwork, and I’m here to say that I did. It’s just that I’m not buying what they’re selling. Sorry, but I’m not.

And you? What do you think? Any ideas on what the “o” stands for in “o’d on yellow”? How about questions…surely, you have a question or two about all of this…

Some guy using the alias of J.W. Harrison wired a hotel room for Robert Maheu and, to this day, no one seems to know who the heck he was. Ummm…Ron? That you?

Photo by David Vives on Unsplash

One of the most difficult parts of figuring out what happened to Ronald Tammen is the inconvenient truth that he had to have reinvented himself. He no longer went by the name Ron Tammen, at least not on paper. He never used his Social Security number, his Selective Service number, or any of the other numbers that had been assigned to him during his formative years ever again. His former life was wiped clean and the feds were keeping mum about whoever it was that he became. It’s likely that very few people were in-the-know then, and, as the years roll by, even fewer are in-the-know now. So what’s a researcher who wants answers to do?

She keeps her eyes peeled for anyone who mysteriously shows up in FBI reports who isn’t identified, like, ever. And she starts with the FBI reports concerning the most in-the-know person she can think of: Robert Maheu. 

I now have a candidate for someone who could conceivably be Ronald Tammen. Oh, I know, I know. It’s likely that this guy was NOT Ron Tammen. However, what I’m about to share with you is evidence that there were people running around doing Robert Maheu’s dirty work and they were doing it anonymously, under assumed names. What’s more, I now know for a fact that Robert Maheu was what’s known in the literary world as an unreliable narrator. In his autobiography, the more important the topic, the more likely it was that he glossed over crucial details or flat-out lied. He kept the really big secrets—including the name of someone who performed a highly sensitive illegal wiretap for him—to himself until the day he died.

Our story begins in October 1960, when Robert Maheu was working on the Fidel Castro assassination plot with Mafia men John Roselli, Sam Giancana, and Santo Trafficante, as well as his pals at the CIA. One day, Roselli approached Maheu and asked him if he could find out if Giancana’s girlfriend was having an affair with one of the guys from Laugh-In.

You want to do this as a Q&A? Good, that works for me too.

What’s Laugh-In?

It was a TV show that ran from 1967 to 1973. It had its funny moments but the writing relied heavily on catch phrases like “Sock it to me” and “You bet your sweet bippy,” which (imo) got old. Dan Rowan and Dick Martin were the comedic co-hosts, with Rowan being the easy-on-the-eyes straight man and Martin being the funny one.

Now, when Roselli approached Maheu, he didn’t mention Laugh-In per se because that show was still seven years in the future. In 1960, Dan Rowan and Dick Martin were mostly playing nightclubs, especially the ones in Las Vegas. 

Who was Sam Giancana’s girlfriend?

Sam Giancana was in love with Phyllis McGuire, one of the McGuire Sisters, and I’ve read in various accounts that the feeling was mutual. The McGuire Sisters were three sisters from Middletown, Ohio, all of whom wore bubble cuts and had matching everything, right down to their suntan-tinted pantyhose and orange patten-leather pumps. They sang familiar fare—sometimes in unison, other times in harmony, never very complicated. Phyllis was the cute, perky one with the wildly flailing arms.

Here they are on the Ed Sullivan Show, with the ever-ebullient Phyllis in the center. (You really need to watch this, because I swear she shoves the sister on the left with her hip about 29 seconds in.)

Here she is by herself.

Was Phyllis McGuire having an affair with Dan Rowan?

That’s what Sam Giancana suspected, and I guess so do I. What can I say? She was a glamorous, vivacious Las Vegas singer. He was a chain-smoking, wisecracking Vegas comedian. Even though she was crazy for Giancana, she may have given into temptation while he was away in Miami Beach plotting Castro’s murder. You have to hand it to Rowan though: if he indeed started things up with McGuire during that period, it was a gutsy, if not insanely stupid move. But then again, if Phyllis was into bad boys, what could be badder than a guy who wasn’t afraid to be seen around town with the girlfriend of Chicago’s Mob boss?

Why did Maheu get involved?

Even a Mob boss can feel fragile at times, and Sam Giancana was feeling especially mopey and vulnerable. He loved Phyllis McGuire so much, he could barely concentrate on the task at hand, which was the assassination of Fidel Castro. Maheu needed to find out if Phyllis was fooling around with Dan Rowan so that Sam could think more clearly about the work he was conducting for the CIA. Dan and Phyllis’s allegedly illicit affair had thus become a matter of national security. If Maheu didn’t find out whatever was going on, Sam was going to go there himself, which, for the good of the country, Maheu needed to prevent. Maheu briefed Sheffield Edwards, the CIA’s director of the Office of Security, about the plan of action, which was to bug Rowan’s hotel room at the Las Vegas Riviera. Shef gave him $1000 for the job but warned Maheu to keep the CIA out of it. 

Who did Maheu hire to do the bugging? 

Robert Maheu hired a private investigator and former FBI special agent he knew from Miami named Edward DuBois to send two of his men to Las Vegas to conduct the bugging operation. The men who were scheduled to go were Arthur Balletti and a former FBI special agent named Fred T. Harris. According to Maheu’s autobiography, the plan was for them to book a room next to Rowan’s room and have them put a listening device on the shared wall so they could listen to whatever was going on in Rowan’s hotel room without having to break in. 

At the last moment, however, Maheu contacted DuBois and told him to send only one man for the job and that Maheu would be sending the second. DuBois sent Balletti, while the other man, the man sent by Maheu, went by the alias J.W. Harrison. Balletti and Harrison met at the Miami International Airport and flew to Las Vegas together, with Harrison using Fred T. Harris’ airplane ticket. At least that was DuBois’ story.

In his book, Maheu only describes one man doing the job—the one who got caught. He never mentioned a second man.

Someone got caught?

Yeah. Arthur Balletti was caught and arrested on October 31, 1960, which happened to be the day after Maheu’s 43rd birthday. Maheu’s guy, the guy who went by the alias J.W. Harrison, got away.

What went wrong?

It’s hard to say what exactly happened because the stories differ depending on who’s talking. One minor difference was that Rowan’s room was below Balletti’s and Harrison’s room, not next door. A major difference was that, in addition to bugging Dan Rowan’s room, they wired his phone.

In his autobiography, written in 1992, Maheu expresses utter bewilderment as to why in the world DuBois’ PI—Balletti—would wire Rowan’s phone when the whole point of the job was to listen to bedroom banter, not to intercept phone calls. “Just why he thought tapping Rowan’s phone would help determine details about his love life, I’ll never understand,” Maheu mused for the people who’d spent good money on his book of occasional facts in a sea of fiction.

But in an FBI interview in 1962, Maheu readily admitted that he authorized the wiring of Rowan’s telephone too. The reason for the change in plans was the CIA had reason to believe the Castro plot was being leaked, beginning with our three swingin’ singles. Giancana could have told McGuire, McGuire could have told Rowan, and heaven knows where it might have traveled after that. What if Dan Rowan told Dick Martin? What if Dick Martin mentioned it to his caddy? What if Dick Martin’s caddy told his bartender? And let’s not forget about everyone’s hairdressers. It could have gotten out of hand fast. 

J.W. Harrison, the man who DuBois said was sent by Maheu but who Maheu denied ever knowing, installed the wiretap, while Balletti conducted the bugging part of the operation. The bugging was considered lawful since they didn’t break into Rowan’s hotel room. The wiretap part, which did involve breaking and entering, was 100 percent in violation of the federal Wiretapping Statute. First the sheriff’s department got involved, then the FBI, then the Department of Justice. And since Harrison had managed to hightail it out of town beforehand, Balletti was on his own.

How did he get caught?

Again, the stories differ. I’m going to go with the summary that was written for the Church committee, compiled from FBI reports, because it makes the most sense:

The hotel manager advised that “…according to hotel records, Arthur J. Balletti checked into the hotel on October 26, 1960 and was assigned Room 331 and that the registration card bears the notation, ‘in room with Harrison.’ Since Balletti’s hotel bill was in excess of $100 and he was not known, the manager and the chief of security for the hotel went to Room 331 and no one was in the room when they entered. At this time, they observed a yellow pad with the notation of time and a date which referred to Dan Rowan and the hotel manager observed in the top desk drawer what appeared to be a recording device. After discussing the bill with Balletti and receiving a somewhat uncertain identification, the hotel manager subsequently notified the Clark County Sheriff’s Office that he had observed what appeared to be a recording device in Balletti’s room and suspected that a listening device might be installed in Rowan’s room.

“The hotel manager and Deputy Sheriff Eversole and another Deputy, name unrecalled, entered Rowan’s room and the hotel manager observed what appeared to be some type of microphone taped to the rear headboard on the bed in Rowan’s room with wires running to the telephone wall box. The hotel manager observed the Deputy Sheriff remove the article from the headboard.”

If you’re wondering why the manager and security chief felt that a $100 hotel bill was worth paying a visit to Balletti’s room, that amount would be equivalent to over $1100 today. Still, it seems like a weird reason for them to go rifling through Balletti’s desk drawers while he was out, but I’m glad they did.

Then what happened?

You know how the CIA relies on “plausible deniability” to get out of every potential scrape they find themselves in? That didn’t happen this time. With all of his meticulous planning and troubleshooting, Robert Maheu forgot to instruct the men what to do if they got caught.

When Balletti was asked who he was working for, he immediately pointed to DuBois who, in turn, directed law enforcement straight to Maheu. Eventually, after lying to the FBI about why he hired DuBois, Maheu vaguely stated that he was using the surveillance to help the CIA obtain intelligence about Cuba through the “hoodlum element.” The DOJ was considering prosecuting Maheu for the wiretap until Sheffield Edwards stepped in and told the DOJ to back off because the prosecution of Maheu would expose sensitive information about “the abortive Cuban invasion in April 1961” (i.e., the Bay of Pigs), which occurred months after Balletti’s arrest and wasn’t exactly pertinent to the issue at hand. In April 1962, the head of the DOJ’s Criminal Division advised Attorney General Robert Kennedy that “it is clear that the national interest will preclude any prosecution resulting from the Nevada wiring case,” and that “prosecutive action will be declined.” In May 1962, Robert Kennedy was fully apprised of the CIA-Mafia plot to assassinate Castro.

Thanks to the hard-loving Sam Giancana, the fast-living Dan Rowan, and the arm-waving Phyllis McGuire, the FBI and DOJ learned about the Mafia-CIA Castro assassination plots early in the game and we got to learn about a mystery man who went by the alias J.W. Harrison.

To this day, the mystery of J.W. Harrison has never been solved. In 1979, a staff report of the House Select Committee on Assassinations stated, “Clearly someone arranged for Harrison’s presence and knows his true identity.” My money is on Maheu, despite his staunch denial of ever knowing J.W. Harrison. You’d think that Maheu would’ve at least mentioned in his book that a guy who went by the alias J.W. Harrison had wired Rowan’s room, though he didn’t have a clue who he was. Perhaps he understood that no one would believe him. 

Did they learn anything else about J.W. Harrison?

A little. We have a writing sample, we have an address, and we have a physical description.

— J.W. Harrison’s handwriting

Here’s J.W. Harrison’s handwriting sample when he signed in at the Las Vegas Riviera on October 26, 1960. The FBI Laboratory attempted to compare his handwriting to another guy’s—someone named J.A. Rolliins—but they came up empty.

I tried to compare J.W. Harrison’s handwriting to Ron Tammen’s. Unfortunately, I don’t have a large enough sample of Ron’s handwriting to make an adequate comparison—just a couple yearbook signatures plus his hand-printed application for college. The big, loopy J in J.W. reminds me of the similarly balloon-like R at the front of Ronald. Other aspects are conceivably similar. But there are notable differences too. J.W. Harrison’s capital “F” in San Francisco and Ron’s capital “T” in Tammen look nothing alike, even though, in cursive writing, people tend to make their capital T’s and F’s the same way except the F gets a crossbar. But handwriting is tricky and it can change. Sometimes it changes gradually over time, and sometimes it happens abruptly, when a person writes a certain way on purpose.

As I was lamenting my lack of Ron’s handwriting samples, it occurred to me that I may be able to obtain two additional samples of Ron’s handwriting—lengthier ones. I’ve written to someone who hopefully still has them and I’ll be back in touch if she does. If so, and if some of the letters do look similar, this may be one of those times when it’s worthwhile to hire a professional. 

–– His address

The address that J.W. Harrison wrote on the hotel registration was 214 W. Water St., San Francisco. Although there is a Water Street in San Francisco, it’s an alley the length of one block with no West or East designations. Also, the house numbers are in the double, not triple, digits. Lastly, if the FBI was attempting to find him, and they were, surely they would have sent someone from the San Francisco Field Office to Water Street to knock on doors. The fact that they weren’t able to locate him tells me the address isn’t real.

— His physical description

On December 14, 1960, the Miami Field Office sent a report to the FBI Director with the subject head “Arthur James Balletti.” In it, they provided updated information from DuBois and Balletti, including Balletti’s description of J.W. Harrison. The description Balletti gave of J.W. Harrison was as follows: “white, male, age 50, 5’10”, 200 pounds, brown hair, balding.”

If these descriptors are true, then J.W. Harrison is without a doubt not Ron Tammen. In October 1960, Ron was 27 years old, so his age is way off. I don’t think Ron would have been balding either. His father and brothers had full heads of hair in their later years. His height is consistent with the description as well as his hair color. I suppose it’s possible that he put on 25 pounds since his sophomore year in college, but I doubt it.

Here’s my issue with that description: For a guy who had little to say about his mysterious counterpart, Balletti seemed to be able to reel off his exact age and dimensions with no room for error. All of the numerical measurements he gave were precise. There’s not even an “s” after 50 to indicate a general age range. Arthur James Balletti was 28 years old when he bugged Dan Rowan’s hotel room. He barely knew his accomplice. To someone in his 20s, 50 is considered way up there. Besides, 50 is old for someone doing undercover intelligence work, particularly someone who’s working on assignment with a low-level investigator like Balletti. Between 1978 and 1987, the average age for CIA operatives was from the upper 20s or low 30s to the mid-to-upper 40s. When James McCord was bugging the Watergate Hotel in June 1972, he was 48. E. Howard Hunt was 53 during Watergate, but he was one of the planners, along with G. Gordon Liddy, who was 41. So while it’s feasible that J.W. Harrison was 50, he would have been at the high end of the spectrum and not typical for his line of work.

I’m wondering if, by the time his interview had been conducted, Balletti had been coached. Balletti worked for DuBois, and DuBois was a friend of Maheu’s. It’s possible that Maheu told DuBois that they needed to keep Harrison’s identity secret and to make up some of the identifying characteristics to throw officials off. We already know that Maheu was capable of lying to the FBI when he wanted to protect the CIA. He lied to them when he first told them why he hired DuBois. Maybe he convinced DuBois and Balletti that, in the interest of national security, they should lie too.

Is it possible that J.W. Harrison was Ron Tammen?

I think it’s improbable that J.W. Harrison is Ron Tammen. However, I also see it this way: we have evidence that Ron Tammen had ties to the CIA’s Office of Security, and it appears he also was known to Robert Maheu. Those two things both apply to J.W. Harrison. It also appears from Ron’s FBI records that Ron was involved in dangerous, perhaps deadly acts—maybe even assassination. But that couldn’t have been all that he did for the CIA. Assassinations didn’t happen that frequently. A hypnotic assassin (if that’s what Ron was) had to have some down days, right? What could Ron Tammen be doing on one of his quieter days?

Here’s a link to a photo from Ron Tammen’s junior year in high school for a school club called the Science Forum. (You might have to sign in to e-yearbook.com first. It’s the bottom photo.)

In the photo, Ron is sitting at a table between his brothers John and Richard. Ron’s attention is focused on what looks like two tall cans, or maybe they’re batteries, that he’s lined up and wired together. The wires lead to the body of an old telephone, which another student at the end of the table is sitting next to while talking into the receiver. By all appearances, Ron’s wiring is making it possible for that guy to talk to whomever he’s talking to. If Ron Tammen was comfortable wiring up a phone in 1950 when he was still in high school, it’s possible that he could become proficient at wiretapping a phone ten years later. 

But if it wasn’t Ron? Well, who’s to say that old, overweight, balding J.W. Harrison wasn’t a colleague or mentor of Ron Tammen’s? At least we now know that, if Robert Maheu did know Ron Tammen, he would have done everything in his power to protect his identity. 

********************

Note: I’ve been spelling John Roselli’s last name with one ‘s,’ which is consistent with many FBI records, Congressional reports, and newspaper articles that spelled it that way. I’ve now come to learn that the official spelling was Rosselli, with two s’s. In today’s post, I’m spelling it with one ‘s’ to keep things consistent. From here on out, I’ll be spelling it with two s’s. John Roselli’s/Rosselli’s birth name was Filippo Sacco.

Breaking news: I just learned something wild about Robert Maheu, the person who I believe was Ron Tammen’s informant

Photo by Dulcey Lima on Unsplash

I have a big announcement. Robert Maheu, the man who I believe was informant LV 366-PC for the FBI, and the man who I also believe informed them about Ron Tammen’s whereabouts in 1973, lived in Tucson, Arizona, during 1960 and 1961, and possibly a little longer. I know this through several ways, the most compelling of which is that his oldest son Peter had graduated from Salpointe Catholic High School in Tucson in 1961. Unlike his two younger brothers, Peter frequently showed up in news articles in the Tucson Daily Citizen throughout his senior year. 

This is a very big deal.

As you may recall, in 1970, LV 366-PC had informed the FBI about Marty Fenster, who had been managing the Grace Ranch in Tucson for mobster Pete Licavoli. The informant let the FBI know that Marty was now working for the Clark County Vending Company in Las Vegas under Frank Milano. 

In a follow-up post, I shared that Robert Maheu could have encountered Marty Fenster at the Frontier Hotel, a Howard Hughes–owned property where the Clark County Vending Company ostensibly had a contract. Maheu’s office was in the Frontier Hotel. That could be how he knew about Marty’s whereabouts in 1970.

This new discovery is much bigger. I think it’s now safe to surmise that, with Maheu living in Tucson during 1960 and 1961, it’s entirely likely that he became acquainted with Pete Licavoli, Grace Ranch, and perhaps even Marty Fenster at that time. 

Chauncey Holt, author of “Self-Portrait of a Scoundrel,” who had CIA and Mob ties, had said that Pete Licavoli was friends with John Roselli and Sam Giancana. Robert Maheu was friends with Roselli and Giancana too, and, in 1960, he’d just begun working with them on a Castro assassination plot.

Holt also said that Licavoli and others were conducting training at Grace Ranch for Operation Mongoose, one of the CIA’s Castro assassination plots. So, if Holt is to be believed, at roughly the same time that the CIA and Mafia were conducting their trainings at Grace Ranch for the assassination of Fidel Castro, Robert Maheu, who was also working with the CIA and Mafia to assassinate Castro, was living in a gorgeous house in the Catalina foothills only about 12 miles away. 

I’m no gambler, but I’d say the odds of this happening without them bumping into one another would be pretty high.